6 ms·
What do you mean by "get this big"? Governments aren't defined by a market cap, but rather by the services they provide to their citizens. Consider that a pri
by arcticbull 6y ago
What do you mean by "get this big"?
Governments aren't defined by a market cap, but rather by the services they provide to their citizens.
Consider that a private company's only goal is to enrich its shareholders, and they have no responsibility to the people or places around them. They are only accountable to their shareholders and the government.
A governments responsibility is solely to its citizens who also control it by vote.
The bigger your biggest companies are, the more powerful your government must become to keep them in line - to ensure they don't break the rules. If you want a small government that is able to retain order and fairness, you must also limit the size of the companies within its purview.
- basilgohar 6y agoThat's a pretty narrow definition of a government. I hardly think that's been the case for most of history and I don't think that's actually the case in the majority of nations to date, even at the surface.
- arcticbull 6y agoCurious what definition you would use? Beyond the obvious, monopoly on the use of force.
- da_big_ghey 6y agoConsider that politicians' only goal is to get re-elected. While the rare exception may exist, that's also true of companies. While governments are accountable in theory, that rarely holds true in practice. I don't think that a "bigger" government, id est one with more regulatory oversight, would help; rather, use the existing court system to enforce what we have. If we lack political will to enforce the existing measures, adding more will not help. A government need not be "big" to have effective court systems and pass some rules on what certain companies can and cannot do.
- arcticbull 6y agoMonopoly rules only exist and matter because of the government. It's pretty obvious that even with them, there's a real pressure for consolidation (and that's efficiency of scale). The natural state of a company is a monopoly. Once you are a monopoly, you don't need to worry about getting "re-elected" any more than a despot does. The free society exists only in the space between these two clashing titans.
- andrewjl 6y agoOne of the ideas behind federalism was that government / the state need not have a monopoly on everything. Corporate monopolies usually only persist due to two reasons: regulatory barriers or technological stagnation. Both are solvable.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoIf not for regulatory barriers, do you really think Bell Systems would ever have lost its monopoly over US telecoms?
- arcticbull 6y agoSure regulatory capture can entrench interests, but there's no reason to believe that in the absence of regulation one big company wouldn't aggregate every major market and just destroy all competition.
- HideousKojima 6y agoGovernments are defined by the populace and land they have sovereign authority over, not the services they provide. That's not terribly different from a corporation being defined by its assets and employees
- tal8d 6y agoWarmer... but not quite. Governments are defined by a monopoly on force. Whoever distinguishes "murder" from "homicide" is the government, and that government's territory stretches as far as those definitions are in effect.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hutzlibu 6y ago"If you want a small government that is able to retain order and fairness, you must also limit the size of the companies within its purview. " Why does the government needs to be big (in size?). It just needs to be strong enough and really connected to its people it represents. Then also a very small country (with a small government) can set up and enforce clear rules on multinational companies, doing buisness within that country. The rules just need to be simple. If they are complicated, it just means, those with the best lawers will win and they are usually working for the corporations.
- arcticbull 6y agoStrength only comes in numbers.
- hutzlibu 6y agoNot really. With numbers come also internal struggles, that weaken the whole system. Look at switzerland or norway for example. They are small in numbers, but don't get really screwed by big corporations either.
- arcticbull 6y agoI suspect that's in large part due to their interconnectedness with the European Union. Neither are Schengen countries, or Eurozone countries, but they both participate in the Single Market - and Norway is a full participant in the EEA. [1,2] Roughly speaking they coordinate on all major rules and policies and practices with the entire rest of the EU and therefore are effectively part of the EU for regulatory and trade purposes. The UK on the other hand, obviously just wrapped up its Seppuku process of leaving the EU, and we're already seeing the relative increase in their being taken advantage of by corporate interests due to their much weaker position. Switzerland and Norway take advantage of the power of the EU to push back on corporate interests, and the UK is getting kicked around as its negotiating power just went down by a factor of 10. [1] https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/countries-and-regions/countries/switzerland/ https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/countries-and-regions/coun... [2] https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/countries-and-regions/countries/norway/ https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/countries-and-regions/coun...
- Quinner 6y agoA corporation that didn't take its customers demands into account would be quite likely to fail. There are many governments that continue to exist by enriching and providing for a small segment of society, and uses force to suppress the demands of the rest of society. A corporation generally doesn't shoot dissatisfied customers. Even in relatively liberal democracies, governments are clearly more beholden to forces other than citizens and their vote. There's a reason why US governments did little to respond to massive BLM protests this summer, as government viewed its responsibility as more aligned to police unions than citizens.
- arcticbull 6y ago> A corporation that didn't take its customers demands into account would be quite likely to fail. Without a government to enforce monopoly rules, it'll just aggregate all its competition into one big blob, and you won't have any choice. Efficiencies of scale mean there's a natural pressure towards consolidation. The terminal state is always one blob that owns everything. Once they do, they can smash any new upstarts, by undercutting prices, or by just buying them too. > A corporation generally doesn't shoot dissatisfied customers. Sure does shoot dissatisfied union leaders though [1] and enslave children to farm cocoa [2], and take down a democratically elected government kickstarting a 36 year long civil war [3]. Also substantially all of the trans-atlantic slave trade [4, 5]. These things were all allowed to happen because the governments in those respective jurisdictions weren't (and in the case of child slave labor, aren't) strong enough to stop them. The idea that "a corporation generally doesn't shoot dissatisfied [people]" is a privileged western position to take based on the current system working pretty well. In places that have weak government, your statement simply does not hold. [1] https://prospect.org/features/coca-cola-killings https://prospect.org/features/coca-cola-killings [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2019/business/hershey-nestle-mars-chocolate-child-labor-west-africa/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2019/business/hershe... [3] https://www.umbc.edu/che/tahlessons/pdf/historylabs/Guatemalan_Coup_student:RS01.pdf https://www.umbc.edu/che/tahlessons/pdf/historylabs/Guatemal... [4] https://www.britannica.com/topic/East-India-Company https://www.britannica.com/topic/East-India-Company [5] https://dutchreview.com/culture/history/voc-dutch-east-india-company-explained https://dutchreview.com/culture/history/voc-dutch-east-india...
- splistud 6y ago"A governments responsibility is solely to its citizens who also control it by vote" And most Western governments are now abdicating this responsibility in the name of political ideals and the stated notion that non-citizens have the right to demand a place in the nation of their choosing.
- arcticbull 6y ago> And most Western governments are now abdicating this responsibility in the name of political ideals and the stated notion that non-citizens have the right to demand a place in the nation of their choosing. Nobody is doing that. However, I'd suggest that even if they were, it wouldn't invalidate anything I'm saying. Non-citizens are permitted to immigrate under various circumstances, defined under naturalization law. Sometimes that's on the basis of being refugees. Sometimes its on the basis of skills and needs. Sometimes its granted in the face of exigent circumstances. In the case of the DREAMers, it's based on the notion that if you're brought into the country as a toddler, then you didn't intentionally commit a crime and the fair thing to do is to let you remain - in no small part due to the huge role these folks play in the economy. The parents who committed those crimes are not granted any sort of amensty.
- ufmace 6y agoI don't think the "responsibility" part is all that important. There are many points about it that can be argued, but I think the more important part is means. Private companies' only effective means to do anything are to produce a product that people freely choose to buy and attract people to work for them (absent a few rare exceptions). Governments have effectively unlimited means to compel people. They can spy on anyone, fine them, throw them in jail, kill them, all for as much and as long as they feel like.