5 ms·
> We can't measure that directly because we can't just expose a bunch of folks to Covid and hope for the best. We can, but medical ethics hasn't caught up yet.
by renewiltord 6y ago
> We can't measure that directly because we can't just expose a bunch of folks to Covid and hope for the best.
We can, but medical ethics hasn't caught up yet. I would participate in a challenge trial, for instance.
- jMyles 6y ago> I would participate in a challenge trial, for instance. Me too. And nearly everyone I know in my risk tier. We had an entire globe of low-risk people willing to be part of the most acute spread, whether for research, for personal immunity, or to be able to isolate for a defined time to protect loved ones, and we squandered it in favor of pseudoscientific horizontal interdictions like lockdowns. It's really an incredible abandonment of basic principles of public health.
- renewiltord 6y agoMedical ethicists believe they've solved the trolley problem by turning their back on the lever and letting Jesus take the wheel.
- carschno 6y agoIf the sample consists of volunteers, it's hardly random. In particular, given that these volunteers are "low-risk people", it means that the results of this experiment will yield virtually no useful conclusions for the higher-risk groups
- jMyles 6y agoSure, I don't mean to suggest that it can be a replacement for RCTs for vaccines. But there's a lot of information we left on the table. We had an opportunity to systematically formulate a controlled acute spread, studying the virology in a longitudinal way, studying the immune response in a more intimate and controlled way (from antibodies to the immune response after antibodies fade), and to examine the prevalence and role of innate immunity. Beyond research, we had a chance to have tens of millions of people with verifiable immunity in Spring or Summer. People who then were in a great position to render aid to the marginalized communities who are instead bearing the brunt of lockdowns. Instead, we traded all that for zero upside. And we have to deal with the enormous side effects of the horizontal interdiction as well.
- zensavona 6y agoExactly, this is the real issue here unfortunately.
- throwaway2245 6y agoA randomly controlled challenge trial would involve deliberately infecting scores of unvaccinated people, putting them at risk, along with anyone involved in the procedure and anyone they come into contact. It would mean handling live virus, which requires a Biosafety Level 3 facilities. And, it's not going to get your vaccine approved any quicker.
- renewiltord 6y agoSee, this is a classic example. You need BSL3 facilities if you want to have a hundred people have it. But the alternative is 27 million people getting it in planes, boats, and buses - none of which are BSL3. That part is okay. Quite the example of the asymmetry. If you engage with the problem you have to operate absolutely perfectly. Way better not to engage with it and kill a few hundred thousand people. After all, no one can blame you for that part. And of course it's not going to get the vaccine 'approved' quicker because yeah, 'approval' is also subject to the same people. But it will let us know if it works and whether it hurts.
- throwaway2245 6y ago> You need BSL3 facilities if you want to have a hundred people have it. But the alternative is 27 million people getting it in planes, boats, and buses - none of which are BSL3. Those things are not true alternatives. I said "it's not going to get your vaccine approved any quicker" in the hope that you would understand: vaccines have reached the point of global distribution without doing the additional deliberate harm of intentionally infecting people.
- renewiltord 6y agoWell, we've taken your approach and killed 300k in the process, so I guess we could play at being tankies in the '90s and say "If only the Communism were properly done" or we could revisit the approach. Of course I am healthy, my family has had the vaccine or the disease and punched through, so I don't really care all that much.
- 6y ago