3 ms·
That's not strictly true: the end-run around the GPL is SaaS - if you are not distributing your software, merely running it on your own servers, then you can ke
by gaius 15y ago
That's not strictly true: the end-run around the GPL is SaaS - if you are not distributing your software, merely running it on your own servers, then you can keep what you've built on a GPL foundation as secret as you like. The most high-profile example of this approach is Google. They do give away a lot of stuff true, but their core tech, like BigTable, is kept under lock and key.
- starter 15y agoTHAT is what I'm after! The SaaS market is the primary vertical my ventures need to dominate at the moment. Distributing software is really not on the list for the foreseeable future. I think you discovered the answer I needed. I'm now confident that the GPL won't be an issue for the time being since most of the code will be staying on our servers. In the future, other licenses may be worth my time to investigate for new products.
- makecheck 15y agoTechnically true perhaps, but morally gray at best. As I see it, a project that's using the GPL is making a pretty clear statement of their intent, regardless of whatever slimy legal loopholes may have been left unclosed. A GPL project author probably doesn't want other people harvesting their work and keeping the changes secret, even if there are technically ways around the GPL's distribution clauses.
- gaius 15y agoFWIW I agree with you, but it is how it is.
- starter 15y agoI'm confused. Are you saying that using private GPL software in the SaaS vertical is NOT ok?
- gaius 15y agoI'm saying that while it violates the spirit of the GPL, it is nonetheless completely permitted. As I say, Google do it.
- starter 15y agoI see. It all comes down to morals. With all the Open Source Community has given me, I'm not interested in stepping on toes. Not sure what the future holds but thanks for making your perspective crystal clear!