3 ms·
Plenty of people consider ARMv8 a better ISA than RISC-V; the addressing modes seem to be a real concern. Those same people mostly consider MIPS to be too simpl
by wmf 6y ago
Plenty of people consider ARMv8 a better ISA than RISC-V; the addressing modes seem to be a real concern. Those same people mostly consider MIPS to be too simple for its own good; obviously this simplicity doesn't completely doom the architecture but there are some long-standing differences of opinion here.
- brucehoult 6y agoThere is plenty of evidence (rather than opinion) that with a decent compiler and hardware implementation the more complex addressing modes don't gain you anything worth the bother in either code size or performance. RISC-V is extensible. If someone really believes that more complex addressing modes are worth it then they can add them as a custom extension. If their chips work out to have better performance/price, performance/area, performance/energy then everyone else will want to copy them and those more complex addressing modes will become a standard extension for RISC-V. There is no sign of the RISC-V community (as opposed to ARM or x86 fans who aren't using RISC-V anyway) moving in that direction.