8 ms·
I still don't understand how they successfully managed to make people think buying shares of a bankrupt company for $350 a pop was a good idea. They pitched it
by lm28469 6y ago
I still don't understand how they successfully managed to make people think buying shares of a bankrupt company for $350 a pop was a good idea. They pitched it as the new BTC or TSLA but it really is just a text book example of pump and dump. They're not "owning wallstreet", at best they're owning a few investors/entities who took way to much risks, and that's it. The smart ones bought their shares at $5 and sold last week at the peak, any one getting in from now is suffering from massive FOMO.
Ronbinhood &co enabled this by gamifying trading, people are just one click away from betting their entire savings based on random social media posts amplified by mainstream media over coverage.
If you learn about something like this via mainstream medias or your friend who had no idea what trading was 2 days ago you can be 100% sure that you're too late to the party
edit: ok, not bankrupt, but clearly not going in the right direction. Either way, not anywhere close to make investors rich quick
https://gamerant.com/gamestop-out-of-business-in-digital-age/ https://gamerant.com/gamestop-out-of-business-in-digital-age...
https://gamerant.com/is-gamestop-going-out-of-business-dying/ https://gamerant.com/is-gamestop-going-out-of-business-dying...
https://edition.cnn.com/2020/09/10/investing/gamestop-store-closures/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2020/09/10/investing/gamestop-store-...
https://www.ccn.com/gamestops-ultimate-destiny-buyout-or-bankruptcy/ https://www.ccn.com/gamestops-ultimate-destiny-buyout-or-ban...
- u10 6y agoGamestop isn't bankrupt, in fact I would say they are in a decent position, at least in the short term. Not worth 350 a share but certainly not 0.
- decafninja 6y agoEven if not sticking strictly to fundamentals, I would say their fair share value is a lot closer to 0 than to 350 though.
- redisman 6y agoI don't see what they have going for them. Squeezed by big ecommerce game stores and subscription services and free-to-play games on all sides. Customers seem to hate their meme-rific trade-in policy "Cyberpunk 2077? best I can do is $5".
- cowmoo728 6y agoGamestop is nowhere near bankrupt. One of the reasons that the trade took off is that Gamestop still has cash on hand and has reasonable (if declining) revenue. On their current trajectory they will go bankrupt, but it could take years. On fundamentals they could be a $20 stock but they were at $4 and still being heavily shorted, which made some people angry.
- Apocryphon 6y agoI don't think people were angry that the price was undervalued, the anger came about when it became apparent that hedge funds had been over-shorting the stock to the point of potential naked short selling.
- klodolph 6y agoI have heard no claims of naked short selling that came with any evidence. Not saying that it hasn’t happened, just that there are other explanations which seem to be more relevant / explicatory here.
- XFrequentist 6y agoWhat other explanation is there for more than 100% of GME stock being sold short (genuine question)?
- fractionalhare 6y agoBriefly: a share which has been sold short can be sold short again by the person who buys it from the borrower/short seller. In practice, this often occurs due to regular market mechanics when a particular company is a hot short target. All that's required is a widespread consensus that the company's financials suck (in not so few words).
- rspeele 6y agoAlice lends his 1 stock to Bob. Bob sells it to Charlie (but is still on the hook to return it) Charlie lends his 1 stock to Dave. Dave sells it to Eddie (but is still on the hook to return it). There is only 1 stock being traded here, but there are two loans (shorts) out on it with obligations to return it.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> The smart ones bought their shares at $5 and sold last week at the peak Loosing a bet doesn't make you a not-smart investor. High risk ventures can be part of any portfolio. In a game of high risk and high returns most bets don't work out. I don't think any less of hedge fund people who "lost their shirts" on this. That is a normal part of the game.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ogre_codes 6y agoBuying GME at $350 makes you... well it's not a good investment, nor good speculation, nor a good bet. I'm not sure what's left that is "good". This is not a normal part of the game.
- decafninja 6y agoBut r/wallstreetbets was saying they could take it to the MOON at $9000!
- StanAngeloff 6y agoThe first time $350 was hit Reddit investors were still building up momentum - it wasn't a bad play given all the money pouring in. I personally executed several trades at and around $350 and all were profitable. The frenzy eventually died down and at that point there was no turning back. I feel sad for all my friends stuck holding shares they've bought hoping for the MOON!
- lm28469 6y ago> Loosing a bet doesn't make you a not-smart investor. People who never traded in their life and bought GME at $350 because reddit promised them big returns (I know a few in my friend circle) aren't smart investors taking part in a risky venture, they just suffer from fomo and have no idea of the risks People who bought a few weeks ago may have made a risky calculated move though, I'm not denying that. People who bought a long time ago and fomented the whole thing for a massive profit are definitely the only one I'd call smart, low risk, perfect execution, comfortable exit. No one will make me believe that the people who bought at $350 are just as smart and taking the same risks as the people who bought at $5. They're not playing the same "game" you're talking about. Head or tails isn't the same as "guess the number I chose between 1 and 5000"
- youeseh 6y agoThis may help shine some light on the "How" and "Why": - https://newrepublic.com/article/161182/bought-tens-thousands-dollars-gamestop-stock-no-regrets https://newrepublic.com/article/161182/bought-tens-thousands...
- nemo44x 6y agoI think the legislation that may come from all of this is to limit margin accounts. When I signed up for an online brokerage years ago you couldn't trade on margin, which meant no option trading or day trading since when trading without a margin account, your cash has to clear. You had to go to their office and fill out forms and have a minimum balance. With Robinhood everyone gets a margin account and the brokerage clearly can't support it with the tiny balances so many of their users carry. Their business model has forced other brokers to follow by offering free trades and everyone is on a margin account. This is a poor practice. I'd support requirements like ensuring balances of at least $10k or more to qualify for margin. Robinhood is purposely designed to encourage day trading and other margin trades many users don't understand or that the infrastructure (not just RH, but the clearing houses, etc) can't and shouldn't support. There's going to be a whole new world of pump and dumps like never before as so many people are hungry for quick money now and taking risks with their rent money they shouldn't be. For what it's worth, the original guy betting on GME had a smart and well researched hypothesis and I hope he made his fortune. But the lemmings following have no business in this kind of thing.
- anm89 6y agoWhile the greater fool strategy may generally be a losing one over enough iterations and time, it is very possible to make huge money on these plays in the short term. It is not always irrational to buy into an overpriced asset. For example GME was wildly overpriced at $100 relative to basically every metric and yet it would have been an incredible buy. I'm not advocating that anyone actually do this, I'm just saying that you are over simplifying by only acknowledging the value side of the equation.
- acct776 6y ago> GME was wildly overpriced at $100 relative to basically every metric and yet it would have been an incredible buy. Can confirm.
- betterunix2 6y agoThe problem is that you need to sell quickly to take advantage of a short squeeze, and the people who bought at $200 could have made a big pile of money last week -- but if they still have those shares today, they will probably never recover their losses. Right now GME is trading at slightly more than $100/share, and while it might spike again tomorrow it will probably continue to decline. The squeeze is over and by now the remaining shorts are hedge funds who sold when the share price was above $300.
- Geee 6y agoNo, they didn't pitch it as a BTC or Tesla. Clearly you haven't been following at all what is happening. The pitch was to cause a short squeeze and then selling when it happens. So that only losers would be the short selling hedge funds.
- allenu 6y agoSo the idea is everyone who buys late can sell high and jump off the ship at the same time? Maybe I'm missing something, but if a whole bunch of people offload a stock, wouldn't that drive the price down, meaning a lot of people outside of the original short-sellers would still lose money?
- icelancer 6y agoThe idea is the short sellers have to cover first due to margin calls at a huge loss, then the retail investors unload.
- MSM 6y agoAgain though, the retail investors unload to who? Everyone knows GME is over valued by an insane amount, who do people expect to be snapping up shares at $500?
- thebean11 6y agoThe short sellers. They are short so they must buy the stock to close out their positions. (not saying this is indeed what would happen, just explaining the though process)
- notyourday 6y ago> The short sellers. They are short so they must buy the stock to close out their positions. This is incorrect. Short sellers only need to close out their positions if: 1. They cannot maintain them. If they can raise funds ( which they did ) they can maintain the positions. In fact they are probably shorting more, short averaging up if they can get a locate. GME yesterday was on a hard to borrow not on non-borrowable list. 2. Their shares are called back. GME looks like a crazy stock around 1998/1999 ADEP(?), I think, which went from sub 3 to over 75 two days before Thanksgiving peaking with a couple of trades over 97 followed by a quick crash into teens and a really slow side into pennies. Some of the short sellers covered by putting up classified ads buying stock certificates from the cause the short squeeze by asking to deliver the certificates crowd a few years later.
- sajithdilshan 6y agoThe hype had nothing to do with the fundamentals of the company. It was about short squeeze and gamma squeeze. The pitching point to buy the stock was that if all the retail investors buy and hold the shares, then ultimately squeeze would drive the price higher. Partially this is true and more than one squeeze happened for GameStop. But for other shorted stocks like AMC, Blackberry or Nokia I'm not sure if the squeeze ever happened and I feel sorry for the people who are still clinging on to those stocks. It could take months, or maybe years to sell them with a break even price.
- blobbers 6y agoDo you think blackberry is ever going to hit a price of $28 again short of a market dynamics play like a squeeze? Break even price? Through what, innovation? Currency inflation?
- okprod 6y agoFrom what I've seen on Reddit and TikTok, many involved are young and holding to make a point, regardless of the pump. A portion of these are also hoping to make it rich, and get rich quick schemes rarely pan out.
- lm28469 6y agoWhat if they've been tricked into buying now to cover the exit of early investors? People keep saying it's not about the money but the ones who keep quiet are making millions
- notyourday 6y ago> From what I've seen on Reddit and TikTok, many involved are young and holding to make a point, regardless of the pump. Most of them bought in highly concentrated margin accounts. They will be force sold by the broker as a result of a margin call.
- okprod 6y agoI don't know, there is some of that but also a ton of people buying like 1 share or 20 shares.
- anonymouse008 6y agoIn today's QE-Infinity Climate - it's not unreasonable to see Chewy's executive management turning GME into a successful e-commerce and brick and mortar play. The e-commerce business is valued at 10x in QE-infinity terms, on adjusted EBITDA, which means it's not far fetched for the story to become $888/share right now. The only thing missing is a constant parade of upgrades from the analysts.
- rspeele 6y agoMaybe if Gamestop pivots to e-commerce they can eventually come up with some way that you could buy a game online and have it delivered fully digitally, without even having to wait for shipping. Especially if they had vendor lock-in, where the games you've purchased digitally are available to you on any device -- but only through your GameStop account. Every time you log into your GameStop account to play the games you've purchased you would see the front page of their store with all the new games they've listed and the sales they're promoting. That business model could really be worth $20B. It would be huge. Like what Netflix did to BlockBuster, but for video games.
- gruez 6y agoBut what's going to be their platform? Consoles? Doubt it, the manufacturers have a lockdown on the platform. PC? They might be able to enter, but they're going to have their work cut out for them considering there's steam, epic, and a plethora of first-party launchers (eg. origin or uplay).
- sjg007 6y agoGamestop could build out a cloud gaming service like Stadia as one possible way to do it.
- tedunangst 6y ago(Spoiler: that is steam.)
- triangleman 6y ago
- soared 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZTr1-Gp74U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZTr1-Gp74U Roaring Kitty (Deep fing value)'s first video from 6 months ago on $GME answers your questions. It started as legitimate investing with some memes on the side, and then turned in memes with some legitimate investing on the side.
- this_user 6y agoThis is indeed how it started. Bloomberg's Odd Lots podcast also had a recent episode with one of the other main guys behind the original, fundamentally driven trade. It's well worth listening to. He makes some good points that the company was indeed undervalued in the teens and lower. Obviously, that is no longer where it is trading, and unless they turn into the Amazon of video games somehow, a valuation of well above $100 seems excessive. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/audio/2021-01-29/how-to-make-the-score-of-a-lifetime-on-gamestop-podcast https://www.bloomberg.com/news/audio/2021-01-29/how-to-make-...
- moofmilker 6y agoWell, in 2020/2021 you start by framing it as "us v. them" where "they" are immoral people having a good, successful, happy life at the expense of you (somehow, details are not important - we live in a post-truth anti-intellectual timeline). Somehow these hedge fund fat cats are rich and I'm poor! Sprinkle in some millennial defeatism ("I'll never be able to afford a house like my boomer parents so why not YOLO my savings?"), add memes, and frame it as some giant way to get back at the 1% without any actual hard work. Then you sit back, watch it unfold, slowly and quietly exit your position as the stock skyrockets, shop for a new yacht.
- trianglem 6y agoIt was a good pitch. Short interest of 140% at one point and the hope of a massive short squeeze. To bad those numbers are not transparent.
- LatteLazy 6y agoNo one ever went bust by assuming the general population are morons with short attention spans.
- throw0101a 6y ago> I still don't understand how they successfully managed to make people think buying shares of a bankrupt company for $350 a pop was a good idea. Just because GME-as-ownership-unit may be overvalued, does not necessarily mean it is overvalued for GME-as-contract-closure-instrument. If you want to focus on GME-as-ownership-unit, as a share in a retail business, that's perfectly valid. But that's not the only perspective.