3 ms·
Except in your sentence it doesn't make any sense because there is no arbitrage between nature and modern healthcare. When prosperity means “throwing away tons
by littlestymaar 6y ago
Except in your sentence it doesn't make any sense because there is no arbitrage between nature and modern healthcare.
When prosperity means “throwing away tons of electronic crap people give each other for Christmas because they have been exposed to ads and social pressure to buy crap” or “flying planes in circle in the sky because people are nostalgic of traveling during lock-down”, then you can't have “prosperity” without harming nature.
- refurb 6y agoAll that crap people buy and flights people take generate economic value that helps pays for stuff like medical care. You can't have one without the other.
- littlestymaar 6y agoNo. “Economic value”, that is GDP, means consumption. We are consuming plane trips, and that counts as valuable because we were ready to pay for it. If I enjoy watching people dig holes and refill it in my backyard, and pay people to do so, this is creating “economic value” because “it bring you pleasure, and you were ready to put a hundred dollar in it, that means it gave you $100 of pleasure” (that's literally how GDP works), it doesn't benefit medical care in any way. And it fact, if I'm paying $1000/h for hole digging, I'm actually harming medical care, because some people would become hole digger instead of nurse / doctors / researchers.
- refurb 6y agoI don’t think you said anything that contradicted what I said. Consumption = creation of economic value = what pays for healthcare
- littlestymaar 6y agoYou missed the point, being: “Economic value” can't “pay” for anything, because it's a “spending” (you pay with what you earn, not with what you spend). From an economic PoV, “economic value” is a spending, and “natural resources” (including work) is the earning. When someone is building/designing an iphone, he's not building a MRI scanner, and the energy consumed in the process isn't going to healthcare either.
- refurb 6y agoYou can’t create economic value without a buyer and a seller, so no it’s not just consumption. And you cant get an MRI without exchanging something of value (whether paying or with your own money or through taxes). Hence the creation of economic value on one hand feeds consumer desires and on the other hand creates value that can be spent on things like health care. You cant have one without the other.
- littlestymaar 6y agoHere, you are talking about “money” and “transactions” which have very little link with the creation of “economic value”, sorry. Since you don't really understand what we are talking about, I can't do any better than advising you to learn a little bit about economics (any econ 101 on coursera would do the trick). Good day.