5 ms·
So what's the main value of this? How people are using it? Is it used like a remote DEV machine that you use through remote desktop/SSH? Is it used to host soft
by mrtksn 6y ago
So what's the main value of this? How people are using it? Is it used like a remote DEV machine that you use through remote desktop/SSH? Is it used to host software developed for Mac? Some use case where you need very high bandwidth for your app?
It looks cool but I'm having hard time to justify the reason for the existence of the service probably because I never used "Mac on the cloud" and I don't know what I am mission out. Can anyone enlighten me here?
- FrojoS 6y agoI assume for development and testing of your Mac app. E.g. if you are not primarily a Mac user and just want to port your Windows app.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoThe price feels high for that, yes? Hardward is relatively inexpensive and falling. Put another way, with this "lease" after a year you could have bought and owned the vehicle. Instead, you're committed to another year. That said, I assume there are security advantages to this model. Better control of access, etc.
- purplecats 6y agothis got me thinking. instead of buying a new mac every 2 years (about 600$+ a year + transition labor I guess), I would rather just use my current mac, and stream into a VM with the latest mac running on really good hardware and use that as a saas. is this a thing?
- martinald 6y agoNot possible really. MacOS has terrible remote desktop software which is really laggy and generally crap even on gigabit FTTH. They all seem to be based off VNC, instead of something closer to Windows RDP which seems to be a lot smarter in how it sends it over (I cannot notice I'm on RDP most of the time). It also has loads more features (for example, it can change resolution dynamically as you go into full screen instead of being static), handles audio well, etc. I could be wrong on this - would be interested to hear if anyone has had a better experience.
- mrtksn 6y agoI wouldn't agree. I often connect to my GF's Macbook to help her out with a code or something like that. You can't watch a video but it is phenomenal to work together on the same thing because it's very easy to connect and has a phenomenal audio link that it feels like you are in the same room. There's almost nothing to mess up, unlike the 3rd party conferencing and desktop sharing software that every time someone is not getting the sound/can't share the desktop/can't unmute the mic. BTW where I live currently, 4Mbps upstream is considered good and the remote desktop works fine on this connection.
- martinald 6y agoThis is what I mean though. You can't watch a video. This works flawlessly on RDP on Windows (will be a little compressed if you are on lower bandwidth). It's a fairly major problem if you're using it as your primary machine. Have you tried RDP? It is miles ahead of anything else I've seen.
- mrtksn 6y agoI have not but I guess if I want to watch a video, why not stream it or download it on my actual machine?
- easton 6y agoWhat if you use the system as your only computer, using other devices as thin clients? Windows/Linux has tons of different ways to optimize for this (RDP with acceleration, Citrix, LTSP/X forwarding), whereas the Mac doesn’t. Which is fair, Apple didn’t design the OS to be used that way, but it’s an annoying drawback.
- fakedang 6y agoI assume the difference will be more prominent if you go into other applications such as cloud gaming. As an addendum, I ran Cyberpunk on my beaten down 4 year old ThinkPad 420 via an EC2 instance (specifically to test out the hypothesis) and it was faster than my usual usage on it.
- agloeregrets 6y agoI think technically speaking Mac Stadium does that. Pretty pricy vs just buying and restoring from time machine. It’s arguable that the needed Mac gains to be worth it are probably more like every 3-4 years and you are throwing most of that away in Remoting in. The M1 is an inflection point too, I would just argue to buy a new Mac mini each time they update it (once every 4 years or so).
- martinald 6y agoPrimarily for CI/CD servers for mobile apps.