3 ms·
It's not generally known, particularly by the generation that was born at the tail end of the Cold War (like myself), and by people born later. We grew up witho
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
It's not generally known, particularly by the generation that was born at the tail end of the Cold War (like myself), and by people born later. We grew up without the fear of that particular flavor of Armageddon.
But MAD is still what keeps the world relatively peaceful. It also gives rise to certain paradoxes - like any attempt to create a better defense against nuclear weapons is also the biggest threat to mankind, because it risks breaking the MAD doctrine and thus inviting a nuclear first strike. For MAD to work, countries in their equivalence class (e.g. US, Russia and China are one class) need to be in lock step with their capabilities, so that no one can be struck without the attacker risking annihilation.
- yesenadam 6y ago> But MAD is still what keeps the world relatively peaceful. There seems a kind of anthropic principle here - it seems successful, but we wouldn't be here talking about it if it had gone terribly wrong, which has come very close to happening more than a few times, apparently. The risk of that is >0, but the cost is...infinite. That doesn't seem obviously worth the gamble, to say the least.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI think it's less of an anthropic principle, and more the realization that it's the only stable equilibrium available once nuclear weapons become available.
- yesenadam 6y agoSorry, by "here" I didn't mean in the sentence I quoted, just in this field. I just don't buy the apparent absolute certainty it won't kill everyone. Then anything else would have been preferable to the "stable equilibrium" we were assured was necessary. But we won't be around to talk about it. That eternally living under MAD is 'the only way' seems to me more like a religious belief than a realization of a fact. A uniquely insane/evil one, however you want to describe killing everyone on Earth. Perhaps it's not considered so evil or insane to do that if you meant well?
- s1artibartfast 6y ago>That eternally living under MAD is 'the only way' seems to me more like a religious belief than a realization of a fact. It is the presumptive fact in the absence of viable alternatives. IF one is discovered, we can revisit the question.