3 ms·
VLC is certainly the program I always recommend to everyone, since it reads all formats and its GUI is perfectly serviceable for most people. But I never use V
by teddyh 6y ago
VLC is certainly the program I always recommend to everyone, since it reads all formats and its GUI is perfectly serviceable for most people. But I never use VLC myself to watch video files, simply because VLC is, and have always been, for years, consistently slower when seeking in all the commonly used file formats which I encounter. It’s not exactly slow, it’s just… noticeably not as fast. It is especially bothersome when skipping through a video to skim it, which I often do. I currently use mpv (https://mpv.io/ https://mpv.io/), which is much faster at skipping, even though mpv does not have a GUI to speak of.
- teraflop 6y agoBy default, VLC tries to seek exactly to the timestamp you tell it to, which may requiring reading and decompressing a significant number of I-frames. Various other players, including mpv and MPC-HC, will instead just snap to the nearest keyframe and display that instead. Try turning on "Fast seek" in VLC's Input/Codecs preferences tab. It's still not quite as fast as other players, in my experience, but it's significantly better.
- teddyh 6y ago> Try turning on "Fast seek" in VLC's Input/Codecs preferences tab. That is a bit better, but still not close to what mpv does. That option also causes VLC to sometimes get “stuck” while skipping, i.e. when you skip many times in quick succession, sometimes the playback gets to a certain point, and any skips will then not skip past that point – you will have to wait a few seconds for normal playback to progress a bit, and then you can skip again. This interrupts your flow, makes you wait (and forces you to partially watch a section you expressly wanted to skip), and is, needless to say, very disruptive when skimming a video.
- Nition 6y agoMPV does seem super fast in general. I had a 4K HDR video file recently that the default Windows player couldn't play (black screen with only audio), VLC played but playback was choppy and the colours were washed out, and MPV played perfectly smooth with correct colours.
- crazygringo 6y agoI've noticed the same thing! And now I'm curious why that is. I would have thought video seeking would be the same in any player for any given specific codec/file. What could explain why VLC really is noticeably slower?
- astrange 6y agoThere might be an accuracy/speed tradeoff. mpv encourages skipping with keyboard shortcuts rather than clicking in a timeline, but I don't think it actually guarantees those shortcuts will skip the same time ahead. It also might be pre-decoding to enable trick play (rewinding etc).
- ripdog 6y agoNo tricks, mpv just jumps to the nearest keyframe, which allows near instant skips. If you want to do time-exact skips, you need to skip to the keyframe previous to your target time and then decode normally from there, causing a delay. I presume VLC does the latter by default and can be configured to do the former.
- astrange 6y agoIf you only want to go forward it's not quite as bad - in a lot of files most frames are skippable (B frames) and you don't have to decode those unless the target frame is in that group (miniGOP).
- BadInformatics 6y agoThere are a fair few MPV GUIs out there. I believe Celluloid is available in the main Debian repos.
- CarVac 6y agoI've used smplayer for ages and like it.
- wjdp 6y agoHonestly quite like the lack of GUI on mpv. It's my quick viewer for media files and does that job very well. I have a few of the keyboard shortcuts memorised but if I need much more than the basics that's when I reach for VLC.