4 ms·
I don't think that this quote is what the article boils down to. IMHO the key information is rather: ""However, severe trauma was prevalent across the social sp
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
I don't think that this quote is what the article boils down to. IMHO the key information is rather: ""However, severe trauma was prevalent across the social spectrum."
At all levels they found a significant number of skeletons with bone fractures.
- sandworm101 6y agoYes, the injury rate may be similar, but the sources of these injuries are likely not. Amongst the ruling classes, horses were the danger. Ride a horse and you will break more bones than the guy who walks to work. Be a friar working in a hospital, not toiling in the fields nor riding horses, and your fracture rate would be much lower.
- wpasc 6y agoBut your risk of bacterial infection probably skyrockets
- ashtonkem 6y agoAlso violence, but in different forms. For lower classes, regular street brawls will produce a lot of injuries. Upper class people will get into some street violence, but the presence of retinues will drastically reduce their incidence. On the other hand, for upper classes (but not monks) war and training for war will produce a ton of injuries, many fatal. Learning to fence and joust are very dangerous activities even in modern times.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> Learning to fence and joust are very dangerous activities even in modern times. Horses. Even today, horses are profoundly dangerous. Go to any hospital warn dealing with neck injuries. Young men fall off motorcycles, and so are generally a little older (16+). Young girls break their necks falling off horses. That particular fall (head first off a horse) is horrible. The neck takes all the load. Helmets protect the skull, not the neck. Obama once said that if he had sons there would be a conversation about them playing football. If I had daughters, they would not ride horses.
- ashtonkem 6y agoI’ll also mention that fencing used to be wildly dangerous to train in. When I learned to fence (Italian school longsword) we practiced with plastic swords and lacrosse gloves. Compared to wood swords with leather gloves this is an incredible safety improvement, and still we broke fingers from time to time. Even modern longsword fencing helms[0] (sport fencing helms can’t handle the abuse) are much tougher thanks to the presence of pre-drilled plate which provides better visibility without reduced protection[1]. 0 - https://i.pinimg.com/originals/4a/15/22/4a1522079ba2951466fb000edcaa97e7.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/4a/15/22/4a1522079ba2951466fb... This type is necessary if you wish to practice with steel swords, among other protective equipment. Steel can cave in regular fencing masks. 1 - Against cutting blows, which is the main issue in practice. Such a plate would be disastrous in actual war, since it would guarantee that any arrow making contact would “bite” rather than deflecting.
- sandworm101 6y agoEvery time I see an evil comic book-style villain with a scared face I am reminded that that look is based in realty. Pre-war, many well-to-do Germans took part in a style of fencing that resulted in regular injuries to the face. A scared face was a badge of status. There were several prominent WWII leaders with facial scars not from battle but from fraternal fencing organizations. A few years later and the comic book supervillains had scared faces too. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academic_fencing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academic_fencing
- TRcontrarian 6y agoInteresting. When I took modern foil fencing classes, it wasn't dangerous in the slightest. The training foils (the long thin bendy swords that people usually think of when they think of fencing) are extremely flexible and have a button on the tip. You score a point by pushing that button against your opponent in a score zone of their body. You wear an electrified vest over your torso with a long wire leading back to the score machine, and when the opponent's sword tip touches your vest it completes an electric circuit. If that circuit is completed at the same time the opponent's foil tip button is depressed, they score a point. Both people have full cage facemasks, and there's almost zero chance of injury short of tripping. Epee fencing, on the other hand, uses a heavier, stiffer sword, so when you poke somebody it can bruise. Sabre fencing is the third modern fencing style, and allows you to score points with the blade (slashing) instead of just the point as with foil and epee. I've never done it but have heard it is the most physical style of the three. This photo is of an epee match, but displays the still considerable flexibility of the weapon and the electrification wires that trail behind each combatant. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89p%C3%A9e#/media/File:Final_Trophee_Monal_2012_n08.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89p%C3%A9e#/media/File:Fin...