4 ms·
One of the things I really appreciate about HN is its ability to get beyond "sound-bite arguments" to really get to a deeper understanding of what can be compli
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
One of the things I really appreciate about HN is its ability to get beyond "sound-bite arguments" to really get to a deeper understanding of what can be complicated arguments. Which is why I really disliked your comment, because your primary sentence includes two lies where you take some words out of context, but hey it must be true because you provided links.
1. Going to your own link, Newsweek did not call "GME investors "far-right extremists"". The article clearly states that far-right extremists were instead using the "stick-it-to-the-man" ethos driving a lot of the GME investor chatter to recruit. There is a huge difference.
2. As other's have pointed out, WaPo published an Op Ed, this was not something under their Editorial Board or a news article. Saying "The Washington Post is comparing the situation to the Capitol riots" is deliberately misleading.
- clarifier123 6y ago>1. Going to your own link, Newsweek did not call "GME investors "far-right extremists"". The article clearly states that far-right extremists were instead using the "stick-it-to-the-man" ethos driving a lot of the GME investor chatter to recruit. There is a huge difference. The point of the article is to associate WSB with far-right extremists. It's a common manipulation tactic, they're making them seem guilty by association. >As other's have pointed out, WaPo published an Op Ed, this was not something under their Editorial Board or a news article. Saying "The Washington Post is comparing the situation to the Capitol riots" is deliberately misleading. People often say that "op-eds don't represent the official opinion of the paper", but it's provably false. There's no shortage of people who are willing to write pro-Trump op-eds, after all, almost half of the country voted for him. How come they aren't getting published in NYT, WaPo etc.? Because publishing an op-ed is a soft endorsement. It doesn't necessarily mean that they 100% agree with it, but it definitely means that they consider the opinion "acceptable".
- prepend 6y ago> 1. Going to your own link, Newsweek did not call "GME investors "far-right extremists"". The article clearly states that far-right extremists were instead using the "stick-it-to-the-man" ethos driving a lot of the GME investor chatter to recruit. There is a huge difference. Yes, but no. It’s called throwing shade and while it is very different from actually showing evidence on a subject and making a claim, it is intended to link the ideas in the readers mind. In middle school it would go like “I’m not saying hn_throwaway is a slut, but I did see her watching Harry Potter and also saw three other boys who say they like her at the theater that weekend.” Both statements are true, but without some other fact they don’t matter so the only reason to mention them is to make a claim without evidence. Especially since I explicitly said I’m not calling you a slut. The article linked does not act responsibly by mentioning these facts in the same article without some link. I think it’s mostly last journalism coupled with trying to click-bait get eyeballs for ads. I too like HN for our attempted critical thinking, and I like that people keep busting through different theories and trying to get to the source of truth.
- tzs 6y ago> In middle school it would go like “I’m not saying hn_throwaway is a slut, but I did see her watching Harry Potter and also saw three other boys who say they like her at the theater that weekend.” > Both statements are true, but without some other fact they don’t matter so the only reason to mention them is to make a claim without evidence. Especially since I explicitly said I’m not calling you a slut. Except that's not even remotely like what the Newsweek article said. Sticking with the middle school comparison, what the article said is that hn_throwaway threw a large graduation party that was open to the public, and some religious cultists came to try to recruit from among the partygoers. There is no attempt to imply that hn_throwaway is a one of the cultists, or approves of the cultists. It is just reporting that the cultists tried to use hn_throwaway's party to find recruits.
- prepend 6y agoThanks for trying to map to analogy. I think the newsworthy piece would be if the religious cultists were going to every party trying to recruit, or there was something special about hn_throwaway that the cultists targeted. The school newspaper writes an article about the party. The article doesn’t answer this question or even indicate whether they tried. So there’s no real reason to report on this other than to link the cultists and hn_throwaway. Actually, the reason is that more students will read the article trying to learn about this cultist thing and hn_throwaway’s recent activity that made them popular among kids.