5 ms·
Hedge funds, as a class, underperform the Dow. Hedge fund managers, as a class, do very, very well. "Except Japan", the author puts in a footnote. The stock ma
by Animats 6y ago
Hedge funds, as a class, underperform the Dow. Hedge fund managers, as a class, do very, very well.
"Except Japan", the author puts in a footnote. The stock market in Japan peaked in 1990 and never came back. The Nikkei peaked at 19590 and is now at 1740.
Could that happen to the US?
- smabie 6y ago1. dow is irrelevant, you should ignore it 2. it's not so easy to determine whether a fund is providing value, you can't just look at returns. The math is more complex than that.
- noisy_boy 6y agoThis is what I too fear when I hear the ever-lasting optimism of long term investing. Could this become a common reality sometime in future? If yes, maybe the other advise about diversifying (real-estate/precious metals etc) isn't so bad.
- Animats 6y agoIn Japan, real estate tanked, too. Once the population starts to decline, real estate drops.
- Clewza313 6y agoFortunately Biden's liberal immigration policy and plan to do another $2T of "money printer go brrrr" should prop up both real estate and stocks nicely.
- noisy_boy 6y agoSeems to me that that's a typical Japanese/Singaporean/Scandinavian problem - if it manifests in other places due to rising quality of living and high societal costs associated with offspring, I'll probably have a different set of worries.
- piva00 6y agoWhy single out Scandinavians given that Scandinavia has one of the highest fertility rates in the EU? It doesn't really feel like a Scandinavian problem but a Western Europe issue, it's much deeper in places such as Southern Europe than Scandinavia (Sweden + Denmark), Spain, Italy, Portugal are running a much deeper demographical crisis than here in Scandinavia.
- bobsmooth 6y agoI'm looking at a chart of Nikkei and its currently 77% of its peak. Even with the March crash, it's shot back up like the S&P has. Where do you get 1740?
- x3sphere 6y agoIt's not at 1740. It closed at 28K last week. Peak was like 38K. Unless you stopped investing completely after the peak you'd still have done alright in the Nikkei. Not anywhere near as good as US stocks, but it would still be better than sitting in cash... especially after dividends. It's now above any point through 1991-2020. Yes still down from the absolute peak, but if you consistently invested throughout those years you'd be well up at this point. But I do think it shows the importance of being diversified. It is recommended to allocate a certain percentage to international stocks. We shouldn't assume the US will continue being the leading market.
- Animats 6y agoYou're right. Bing result: [1] "Nikki Co Ltd" on left, history of the Nikkei index on the right. I knew the Nikkei index had gone down for a long time, but not that far. [1] https://www.bing.com/search?form=MOZSBR&pc=MOZI&q=nikki+index+history https://www.bing.com/search?form=MOZSBR&pc=MOZI&q=nikki+inde...
- ojbyrne 6y agoI’m no expert on the Japanese market, and I understand that this did happen, but I think you’re missing a digit in your second number. Googling around seems to support that.
- csa 6y ago> The Nikkei peaked at 19590 and is now at 1740. Nikkei 225 is at ~28k right now. The peak was ~39k in Dec 89. Where did you get your numbers from? The real numbers are certainly bad, but not nearly as bad as you are representing.