4 ms·
...and here's a financial columnist (ie. an expert) writing about it: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-29/reddit-traders-on-robinhood-are-on-
by gruez 6y ago
...and here's a financial columnist (ie. an expert) writing about it:
https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-29/reddit-traders-on-robinhood-are-on-both-sides-of-gamestop https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-29/reddit...
>Market makers stand ready to buy or sell stock from or to customers; they try to buy for a bit less than they sell at, and pocket the spread. If you go out into the market and say “hey I’ll buy anyone’s stock for $10,” and a really smart hedge fund comes to you and sells you stock for $10, that’s probably bad. You’ve probably made a mistake. The hedge fund is selling you the stock for $10 because it knows it’s worth $8. This is called “adverse selection.”
>More subtly, if a really big mutual fund comes to you and sells you stock for $10, that also may be bad. The mutual fund is probably selling lots of stock, because it’s so big; it sells you a little, then sells a little more, then a little more, until it pushes the price down to $8. The mutual fund isn’t necessarily smart, but by virtue of being big and doing big trades, it moves the price; if you are on the other side of its trades, you get run over. This is also a kind of adverse selection: You buy at $10 and are stuck selling at $8. Part of the spread that market makers earn in public markets—the difference between their buying and selling prices—compensates them for adverse selection, the risk of being run over by a counterparty who knows something they don’t.
>Market makers, the textbook theory goes, would much rather trade with retail orders. Retail investors generally don’t know much, so if you buy stock from them you’re probably not making a mistake. And retail orders are generally small and uncorrelated: One investor buys a little, another comes along a moment later and sells a little, it’s all pretty random, and you’re not facing an avalanche of steady sell orders that push the price down. Trading with retail is so nice that market makers—wholesalers—will both give retail orders a tighter spread (pay more to buy their stock, charge less to sell stock to them) and pay their broker for the privilege of doing it.
- briefcomment 6y agoThat's fine if market makers stick to the rules. What do you make of some of what Citadel has done before? https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-07-21/citadel-securities-fined-by-finra-for-trading-ahead-of-clients https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-07-21/citadel-s... https://www.sec.gov/news/pressrelease/2017-11.html https://www.sec.gov/news/pressrelease/2017-11.html
- tedunangst 6y agoI think if you had started with "sometimes they don't offer as much price improvement as they promised" that'd have been more accurate.
- briefcomment 6y agoThe upshot of this is that Citadel is selling retail GME at slightly elevated prices for profit. This will certainly contribute to higher GME prices. If Melvin is still short, Citadel is in a predicament. If they want the price as low as possible for Melvin’s sake, they need to actually provide the best price. I thought that was funny.
- smabie 6y agoI guarantee that Citadel Securities isn't taking into considering what Citadel capital is doing. It's just not how firms like that operate. Every desk is trying to maximize pnl, end of story.
- gruez 6y agoThere were no allegations that they provided a worse price than the NBBO (ie. the price you'd get if there wasn't PFOF), just that out of all the firms offering PFOF, robinhood didn't choose the best one for their customers.
- briefcomment 6y agoDid you read the SEC release? “But the SEC’s order finds that two algorithms used by Citadel Securities did not internalize retail orders at the best price observed nor sought to obtain the best price in the marketplace”
- gruez 6y agoPresumably > [...] the best price observed [...] > [...] the best price in the marketplace [...] refers to the prices that they can get through all sources (ie. including PFOF firms aka market makers), not just NBBO.