3 ms·
Hopefully this takes off. After years of complaints and issues with rampant deletionism and abusive editors, Wikimedia has finally started to collect statistic
by bane 15y ago
Hopefully this takes off.
After years of complaints and issues with rampant deletionism and abusive editors, Wikimedia has finally started to collect statistics on how this has negatively effected the quality, depth and breadth of the project.
I can't find the Wikimedia Foundation report on this (it coincided with the great programming deletion incident), but it was almost universally negative. Some of the more recent data collection tells a similar story, it shows that new users, while attempting to make good faith contributions, are quickly drummed out of the place by established wikipedians via negative comments and rampant deletionism.
Despite this, and years of evidence that this is a serious problem (to the point of being blindingly obvious) with the project, the foundation hasn't taken any particular move to rectify it. I fear they will never get around to doing anything, or the response will be tepid and pointless.
With bits being basically free these days, there's just no real reason to limit Wikipedia to just being a duplicate of a Paper-and-Ink encyclopedia.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- olavk 15y ago> With bits being basically free these days The work required to maintain quality is not free though. The larger Wikipedia becomes, the more resources are needed to ensure a high quality. There is already a system completely free of "deletionism" with limitless scope which anyone can publish anything on. Its called the web. Why do people want their favorite topic published on Wikipedia rather than on their own page? Because they want the additional authority which comes from being on Wikipedia. But this authority comes from quality control. I think some of the complaints against deletionism could be resolved with independent domain-specific wikipedias with different rules. For example a programming language-pedia could allow original content written by the language designers, something that is not appropriate for wikipedia.
- bane 15y agoWhy do people want their favorite topic published on Wikipedia rather than on their own page? Because they want the additional authority which comes from being on Wikipedia. But this authority comes from quality control. I actually find wikipedia's aggregation and summarization of information just as, if not more, valuable than the authority angle. There actually are some quite interesting domain localized wikis around, on top of the random wiki for a game or fan wiki (or encyclopedia dramatica or conservapedia for that matter) http://www.wikia.com/Wikia http://www.wikia.com/Wikia http://www.wikispaces.com/ http://www.wikispaces.com/