4 ms·
This looks really nice. I love it. But to be honest, nothing about it feels "NES" to me.
by Waterluvian 6y ago
This looks really nice. I love it. But to be honest, nothing about it feels "NES" to me.
- allenu 6y agoIt looks more SNES to me, including the controller.
- cjones26 6y agoI was thinking SNES or GameBoy!
- anthk 6y agoThe NES is a dark palette, with often games just having a single colour background and a few sprites here and there. At least is how I remember those games.
- noobermin 6y agoThat was indeed due to hardware constraints on the machine [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QaIoW1aL9GE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QaIoW1aL9GE
- hnlmorg 6y agoThere isn't really a default "feel" for the NES. Different games would have their own distinct style. The key thing about this CSS framework is that it looks "8-bit" and fun, both of which are true of the NES; rather than it being a literal port of the NES look and feel to CSS. Names are seldom meant to be taken literally but the fact that people are comparing this to a literal Nintendo Entertainment System seems to me that at least the name here is good enough in conjuring peoples expectations otherwise it wouldn't be possible to make that literal comparison in the first place.
- Waterluvian 6y agoI think a big part of the feel of NES is that there's only certain colours that are valid. And that palettes are limited in size so too many colours at the same time breaks that feel.
- hnlmorg 6y agoThe NES had a 54 colour pallet with up to 25 colours on screen (without mid-refresh pallet swapping, a technique some games employed to access more colours). By contrast NES.css uses 12 distinct colours. So how exactly is NES.css breaking "that feel"? The biggest issue I complaint I could make about NES.css is that it's type face has a weird ligature with "fi" which is somewhat distracting from the rest of the text. But even that is forgivable considering this isn't a serious project. And before the obvious comments that "the type face isn't the same as in ${NES_GAME}": the NES, like all 8-bit systems I've programmed on, does allow you to define your own type faces as well. Thus Capcom games have different looking letters to Hudson games to Nintendo's own releases. I've got a NES and a Famicom (plus a Famicom FDD and 3D System). I still play them regularly. This CSS framework is clearly just a bit of fun but it does capture the general aesthetic of the era. All these complaints about colour pallets, while demonstrably wrong, is just nitpicking of the highest order. And the fact that I got downvoted in my earlier comment for saying "naming things is hard" (a point so true it has it's own joke) is pretty evident of just how ridiculous the complaints are.
- NobodyNada 6y ago> NES.css uses 12 distinct colours. So how exactly is NES.css breaking "that feel"? Some of the colors used here don’t exist in the NES palette — for example, the NES cannot display bright yellow (the best it can do are are the colors of the coins in Super Mario Bros. or the colors of Brinstar enemies in Metroid). The NES does not at all look “vibrant” or “crisp”, especially after all the artifacts from its cheap analog video generator. > the NES [...] does allow you to define your own type faces Yes, but (unless you want to do some really awkward tricks) the characters must be aligned to an 8x8-pixel grid. The text in this page is ~9x12 or something like that (including spacing), and the alignment is not consistent throughout the page. > All these complaints about colour pallets, while demonstrably wrong, is just nitpicking of the highest order. Sure, it’s definitely nitpicking. This framework looks great: it perfectly captures the “faux-8-bit” style that’s popular today. And it’s true that the NES is now the representative console of the 8-bit era. However, it’s also true that the NES (like every console of that era) had its own distinctive look-and-feel beyond just “big pixels”.
- lensopra 6y ago"Names are seldom meant to be taken literally but the fact that people are comparing this to a literal Nintendo Entertainment System seems to me that at least the name here is good enough in conjuring peoples expectations otherwise it wouldn't be possible to make that literal comparison in the first place." People are only making the comparison because it's in the name. They're making the comparison and finding it turns out far short of their expectations. If it wasn't called NES.css, people wouldn't bothering comparing it to the NES, and they certainly wouldn't complain that it doesn't look like NES because the name wouldn't have implied it. So it's a bad name.
- noobermin 6y agoI usually hate HN nitpicking like this but I have to agree. The author could have called it 8bit.css instead of NES.css because the NES was a specific thing that had specific colors and style.