6 ms·
I think the more interesting part of the story (if I'm reading it right) is he paid $5000 to completely own a company with millions in assets.
by rwmj 6y ago
I think the more interesting part of the story (if I'm reading it right) is he paid $5000 to completely own a company with millions in assets.
- njharman 6y ago> own a company No "owned the publicly traded shares of a company". Those shares are almost certainly non-ownership, voting shares. And if they are it's possible/probable that founders/investors/others hold an arbitrarily large multiple of traded shares or options for shares or convertible bonds or whatever. What he owns is (somewhere in the line of creditors) the right to some part of assets if it's dissolved (sold, enters bankruptcy) exact triggers and rights are complex and varied.
- psychlops 6y ago> What he owns is (somewhere in the line of creditors) the right to some part of assets if it's dissolved (sold, enters bankruptcy) exact triggers and rights are complex and varied. After all liabilities are deducted. Which usually means nothing.
- pantalaimon 6y agois that really how it works?
- VBprogrammer 6y agoUnless there was something fishy about the share classes. Non-voting shares perhaps?
- londons_explore 6y agoYes, but it's possible the company also had a bigger debt than assets and no hope of turning things around...
- sn_master 6y agoNot sure about this case, but owning all trading shares doesn't mean owning the company. A company may have only 2% of its value as public shares and the rest owned by the company itself.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- koolba 6y agoIf you own all the shares then you can control the company via voting control. That’d generally allow you to prevent the issuance of new shares and you could hand pick the board as their terms expire. It’s not immediate, but you’d eventually be in control of everything.
- brockwhittaker 6y agoNot all shares have voting power, and even so the voting power of those shares (if they were 2% of the company for example) may be proportionally tiny compared to the founders/board/execs. For example shareholders don't have any control at FB, since Mark controls 51% of the voting power.
- YZF 6y agoIt's fairly unusual to have companies with this sort of structure. Why would you ever buy shares in a company that doesn't pay dividends and where you can get infinitely diluted and have no control? (other than for speculative reasons)
- recursive 6y agoMaybe the future potential of dividends?
- echelon 6y ago> doesn't pay dividends Tech/growth doesn't pay dividends as dividends are a signal your business is done growing. Dividend companies would rather return capital to investors than place more bets and keep growing. Tech and growth stocks have minted many millionaires. And sometimes overnight. This is also why growth companies sometimes don't reach profitability. They're spending their revenue eating the rest of the market and gaining monopoly. > no control? People that invested in Facebook made lots of money. They were probably fine with the arrangement. If they stop being fine with it, the stock price will decline.
- FabHK 6y agoHe owned the equity, and therefore theoretically had control over its management. The firm might still have a lot of debt, so be owned largely by banks (or bond holders). Firm value = equity ("market cap") + debt + various, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enterprise_value https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enterprise_value
- caminante 6y ago> He owned the equity, and therefore theoretically had control over its management. Except, for example, if there were different share classes with voting rights or if the "float" is small [0]. [0] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/basics/03/030703.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/basics/03/030703.asp
- Lazare 6y agoThere's some more info here: https://www.forbes.com/2006/08/25/naked-shorts-global-links-cx_lm_0825naked.html?sh=4fb88a4c8400 https://www.forbes.com/2006/08/25/naked-shorts-global-links-... Global Links was trading around 10c a share with ~350 million shares, for a market cap of around $35 million. They implemented a 350:1 reverse share split, which in theory should have resulted in them having a stock price of $35, 1.1 million shares, and a market cap of around $35 million. For some reason, it took longer for this to shake out than expected; in the immediate aftermath it was reported that enormous quantities of Global Links stock was still trading, and the share price had actually declined to a 8 cents. Presumably, some systems were reporting "old" numbers (pre reverse split) and some "new" numbers (post reverse split), and I'm sure an enormous amount of confusion resulted. And it was at this point Simpson reckons he bought 1.2 million shares for a bit over $5,000. That's less than 1/3 of a cent per share, which seems wildly off (the share price was 10 cents pre reverse split, and would have been expected to be $35 afterwards), but given that it seems a lot of computer systems were not handling this correctly, who knows what he was told by his broker? So...obviously Simpson did not purchase 110% of a company, and he definitely didn't do so for 0.01% of its market cap. I rather assume his broker had told him that he had done so, but that seems like fodder for a lawsuit between him and his broker over their buggy systems, but it doesn't tell us much else. It's possible he might have ended up owning 3.6k shares (about 1/3 of a percent of the company), but even that seems doubtful if it actually only cost him $5k. Anyhow: > I think the more interesting part of the story (if I'm reading it right) is he paid $5000 to completely own a company with millions in assets. I think the better reading of that is some guy found a bug in a broker's system that caused it to tell him he'd done that, but it would have been obvious to all concerned that whether he'd ended up with 0 shares, ~140 shares, or ~3.5k shares, he definitely didn't have 1.2m shares, since they never even existed.
- phlo 6y agoJust looking at the numbers here, this could just be a case of a sign getting flipped somewhere along the way. Global Links intends to do a reverse split, replacing 350 old shares (worth 10¢ each) with one new share (worth about $35). For the sake of argument, let's say they mixed up the ratio in their split filing. Instead of doing a reverse split, they do a forward split, replacing each share of old stock (10¢) with 350 shares of new stock (about one third of a cent, each). The shares trade at a somewhat high volume, because each share is worth a fraction of a cent. Simpson notices that, after a 350:1 reverse split, Global Links ought to have about 1M shares outstanding.¹ He also notices that the current trading price is a fraction of a cent. Small enough to make this a worthwhile experiment. He acquires about 1.2M shares without moving the price too much. He also doesn't question how this was possible to happen within a day or two. After the split, Global Links has some 100B shares outstanding. Simpson's position of 1.2M is less than one percent of that, so the shares continue trading as before. ¹ He might be combining multiple sources of information here. Perhaps his brokerage doesn't show reference data, so he combines the price he sees in his brokerage's app with reference data from Yahoo!finance or something.
- m3kw9 6y agoOutstanding vs float will tell you this may not be be possible