4 ms·
I agree with your points on trading frequency, but I still think Robinhood is good for people rather than bad. I think the alternative destination for a lot of
by sokoloff 6y ago
I agree with your points on trading frequency, but I still think Robinhood is good for people rather than bad.
I think the alternative destination for a lot of that Robinhood money isn’t “Vanguard VTSAX” but rather slightly positive lifestyle inflation/expenses.
To the extent that’s the case, all the gamification and reinforcement is creating a behavior that’s better than the likely alternative. (Returns are not good if your total lifetime investment trades are zero.)
- stouset 6y agoI've been debating a lot in these comments, but I do want to take the time to appreciate this point of view. It's definitely one I hadn't considered. If Robinhood is getting people who otherwise wouldn't save to invest, even if they're getting worse returns than they would at somewhere like Vanguard, then I could definitely reconsider my perspective that they're a net-evil. I'm not entirely sure I buy that story, but it's absolutely a reasonable perspective and one I'll keep in mind in the future when evaluating new information about Robinhood.