4 ms·
It’s scary how much conspiratorial thinking is gaining traction in the GameStop story. Despite the narratives about people buying GameStop for altruistic purpo
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
It’s scary how much conspiratorial thinking is gaining traction in the GameStop story.
Despite the narratives about people buying GameStop for altruistic purposes or for sticking it to Wall Street, it’s obvious that most people bought because they were told the trade couldn’t fail and this was an easy way to double their money (or more).
When it doesn’t work out, I’m worried that people will reach for more conspiracy theories instead of realizing that the latest GME buyers were always guaranteed losses.
- TuringNYC 6y agoWhen I get explanations like “you can’t buy or sell for your own good” on a funded account without leverage, at a time where the odds of money were sky high, it does seem fishy. People on WSB have been YOLOing entire accounts to zero for months, where was the concern when people were losing money? Why the concern when they are actually making money? Also, if there is a good regulatory explanation, why not just give that, instead of thin statements like “we’re blocking these trades for your own good.” I’m open to reasonable explanations with evidence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ahmedalsudani 6y agoThe messaging was not forthcoming, I’ll grant you that. But they are actually correct if you take a step back. Protecting the DTCC protects all brokers and thus in turn protects their users. The regulations and the practices followed in the industry are to protect against against real scenarios which can lead to brokers collapsing and investor funds being decimated. Maybe it would have looked better had robinhood come out and said “we don’t have enough liquidity”, though that’s still not a reassuring message for their users.
- sidibe 6y agoI remember the MMM ponzi scheme that was in a bunch of countries including Nigeria. When these things go south people always need an outlet to blame for denying them their free money they thought was coming and better if its a third party and not themselves or whoever duped them into investing. People were furious at editorials or government officials trying to dissuade others which may or may not have brought it to an end. Here its going to be the brokers fault for not being able to let people open more positions, otherwise it certainly would have kept going up and certainly at some point there would have been a price they were willing to sell at.
- 13415 6y agoCommon, I may not know enough about the stock market to be opinionated about this case in particular, but when literally billions are at stake, conspiracies about mild collusion between brokers and market manipulation are really not that far-fetched.
- mancerayder 6y agoIt's puzzling that people find it surprising that the situation caused speculation and "conspiracy theories." It's frustrating that the phrase "conspiracy theory" is used as a way to dismiss skepticism. I hear more and more hand-wringing that conspiracy theories needs to somehow be addressed. And it's annoying that given how complex the situation is, and how little transparency in the market there is, we think that one narrative by authorities should be taken at face value. If you truly dislike conspiratorial thinking, then it seems the best possible reaction is to reply calmly explaining to the conspiratorialists what happened and buttressing counter-claims of the skepticism where it exists.
- theknocker 6y agoDescribe the way this happened to multiple stocks across multiple brokers -- sometimes speculatively, by the admission of the brokers themselves, -- and you tautologically describe a conspiracy to manipulate the market.