3 ms·
I see the most promising line as actually being something considerably different from Wikipedia, rather than an opposition to it, which despite the top-line rhe
by _delirium 15y ago
I see the most promising line as actually being something considerably different from Wikipedia, rather than an opposition to it, which despite the top-line rhetoric does seem to be what the proposal is hinting at.
Wikipedia aims to be a summary of existing sources (books, journal articles, newspapers, etc.), with citation to where it got its material, but originating nothing; basically, the ultimate tertiary source. I think that's a useful thing to have, but it's not the only possible thing you could imagine building.
"True and useful" is a rather different set of criteria, and there is a whole space of websites that could pursue that, ranging from some that already exist (music and literary fansites, some academic wikis, knowyourmeme.com, Everything2) to many that don't yet.
- JulianMorrison 15y agoFor one thing, it implies the ability to work on primary research right there in the site. It would need sufficient justification to be accepted as "true" and it would need a "use" to somebody even if only in the same field, but that covers basically all well conducted academic research.