3 ms·
To my surprise, All the Dell servers we have try to keep the noise at a minimum unless they're pushed to their max. I'm not aware of the any other servers, swi
by bayindirh 6y ago
To my surprise, All the Dell servers we have try to keep the noise at a minimum unless they're pushed to their max.
I'm not aware of the any other servers, switches or actively cooled equipment tried to do that.
IBM BladeCenter H is the worst offender: "Is acoustic management enabled? No? OK, everything is at full speed, then".
- MasterScrat 6y agoRecent HP servers do the same, and are actually quieter in my experience. But yeah as soon as you put an unsupported HDD or extension card in there, it'll assume the worst and spin everything full blast.
- bayindirh 6y agoTrying to keep the noise is at minimum is a noble thing to pursue I think. Otherwise it's deafening when it's working in the system room. In an HPC environment that doesn't matter much, anyway. Heh.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ashtonkem 6y agoI think that small businesses and home buyers have begun to make noisier (heh) demands for quieter servers. I assume that a sizable percentage of the 1U market is going to small businesses that don’t want their printer closet sounding like it’s trying to take off.
- detaro 6y agoThe more usual small business form factor is less-deep 3-4U cases that can be used as a tower or rackmount (once we go past small NAS boxes). Or shallow 1U with low-power parts for routers/small appliances. "Proper" 1U servers feel more like a thing for larger places, where density starts to matter more. Not sure why so many comments here focus on 1U.
- ashtonkem 6y agoI think instinctually it feels like 1U is what you should buy if you don’t need top of the line. That was my assumption as a non-hardware guy considering a home rack. I changed my mind once I found out about the noise issue.
- bayindirh 6y agoYou can get many top-of-line servers for various scenarios in 1U configuration. It can be quite packed up to a point (including GPUs). For home use servers, if you want 1U form factor, you can take a look at Dell's shallow 1U servers. They're pretty modestly powered but small, I think relatively silent and easy to maintain. Higher end servers have some fun features like advanced BMCs and such, but they come with relevant price tags, power consumption and noise. You can also look at SME tower servers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoBecause decommissioned 1U is the cheapest entry into homelabbing (check labgopher)
- detaro 6y agoThe usual recommendations are R720 and DL380 though? neither of which are 1U.
- bayindirh 6y agoR720 and DL380 are old, very ubiquitous servers. They are good workhorses and parts are plenty. Also they're not very closed platforms. They're not very silent though. However with an iLO or iDRAC license, they're joy to administer and use. They're also very reliable too.
- Symbiote 6y agoLess fan noise is less airflow, which means less cold-side air wasted.
- colejohnson66 6y agoI thought fan noise was also affected by the fan’s mechanics? Like, the bearings and such? Sure, you’re not going to get the same performance out of a silent fan as a jet engine, but the noise gains (heh) are worth it in most cases.
- bayindirh 6y ago> I thought fan noise was also affected by the fan’s mechanics? In a 1U server, you're running 5-7 tandem mounted, counter rotating Delta fans which can spin up to 18KRPM. They're in a confined space, have big cores to drive them and they need to supply a blanket of airflow to get things cool. Higher efficiency components and a good implicit airflow design affects much more than the fans themselves, since there's not much space to optimize the fan design itself compared to the airflow as a whole inside the server. Moreover, more intelligent system management solutions with more sensors both inside the chips and on the motherboard allows the BMC to see the whole picture and manage these fans in a more informed manner.
- smiley1437 6y agoI remember going to a Bladecenter demo at an IBM facility when they first came out, and the demonstrator pulled something that triggered the fans to go on HIGH and the way it wound up like a jet engine was so comically loud the entire room of 30 guests all broke out laughing Here's an idea of what it was like: https://youtu.be/pS8h8z1c0bI?t=106 https://youtu.be/pS8h8z1c0bI?t=106
- bayindirh 6y agoIn the video you can hear only one of the two. Other one is connected to other power supply. We had a lot of them, with full configuration, at full load. Go, figure. They can generate a lot of heat though.
- smiley1437 6y agoGood lord, must have been like a wind tunnel in the back of the rack! To be fair, they ARE impressively CPU dense