6 ms·
I fully disagree. If I had $10M, I could retire today, never work again in my life, and my income would be $0. However, I could easily spend $200k/year and hav
by simonebrunozzi 6y ago
I fully disagree.
If I had $10M, I could retire today, never work again in my life, and my income would be $0. However, I could easily spend $200k/year and have a great lifestyle, without reducing my wealth, inflation-wise. Some people say I could even spend as high as 4% of my wealth annually [0] - which I personally don't agree with.
Vice versa, if I had negative $200k wealth (student debt, etc), and an income of, say, $100k/year while living in the Bay area, I would probably remain "poor" and be constrained to a thrifty lifestyle for a long, long time.
[0]: https://www.schwab.com/resource-center/insights/content/beyond-4-rule-how-much-can-you-safely-spend-retirement https://www.schwab.com/resource-center/insights/content/beyo...
- BerislavLopac 6y agoIt sounds like the best measure would be neither wealth nor income, but expenditure...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 6y agoAs a measure of lifestyle, to a degree. Although the anomalies are obvious: the upkeep costs of a lavishly appointed London mansion a multimillionaire owns are certainly lower than the rental on a much smaller flat (and probably a fair bit less than the property appreciates in value). And wealth is a source of power and claim on future spending. The average person spending $100k per annum does not have the capacity to decide nobody in his family need ever work again like Warren Buffett could, never mind his power to move markets.
- yyy888sss 6y agoI'd say what matters is whether you can afford something and all, and then to a lesser extent the quality of that good/service. For example, most people in the US can at least afford a cheap used car, and can therefore go pretty much anywhere. Of course, it's nicer to have a Bentley, but a luxury car still sits in the same traffic and has to obey the same speed limits as everyone else. In the developing world however, the rich always have cars, but many normal people can not afford one at all.
- Jedd 6y agoUsufruct makes this a difficult & poor measure, also. Even well-off (but far from wealthy) people - think contractors on say USD$200-500k / year - can architect their financial arrangements via a Pty Ltd / LLC to minimise on-paper income as well as expenditure. Enjoying full use of an asset to which you, personally, have no ownership and no cost of maintenance, confounds assessments of this demographic all the way through to the private-jet crowd.
- refurb 6y agoPresumably if you had $10M it wouldn't sit under your mattress but at a minimum would be in a bank generating interest. So you would in fact have income.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoNot if the interest is lower than inflation.
- refurb 6y agoHuh? You may not have a real positive return, but you'd still have income.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoConsuming interest is a huge part of the problem. It's a predatory and destabilizing action that has been prohibited (and for good reason) by Islam, Christianity, and Judaism thousands of years ago. Please do not perpetuate the problem by consuming (or paying) interest. It's the least we can do.
- Gunax 6y agoBut how did you attain that wealth? Wealth is unspent income. You could have two individuals who earn $1000. But if one saves $1 and the other saves $100, then the latter is 100x wealthier. But is he really have 100x the lifestyle? No, one spent $999 and the other $900. They are approximately equal. Considering that most people don't save anything (even in wealthy countries) it's not difficult to have 10x the average wealth.