11 ms·
Medieval Cambridge skeletons reveal injuries to manual labourers
- polycaster 6y agoThe article boils down to: "We can see that ordinary working folk had a higher risk of injury compared to the friars and their benefactors or the more sheltered hospital inmates" (ie. 44% compared to 32%/27% having bone fractures). Somehow I fail to see how this is surprising.
- Vervious 6y agoI guess most research shouldn't be surprising, otherwise there'd be an eureka every day
- polycaster 6y agoThere's certainly value in their finding. My comment was more targeted at the usual HN audience perhaps expecting an intellectually stimulating story.
- ejolto 6y agoIt's important to have data to back our unsurprising assumptions. Lots of unsurprising assumptions have turned out to be false.
- kibwen 6y agoIndeed. Relatedly, here's Popular Science's list of articles in the category "Science Confirms The Obvious": https://www.popsci.com/tags/science-confirms-obvious/ https://www.popsci.com/tags/science-confirms-obvious/
- Cederfjard 6y agoI’d be more interested in a list called “Science Disproves the Obvious”. Anyone got one laying around?
- taeric 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_common_misconceptions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_common_misconception... is about the best I know of.
- libraryatnight 6y agoThis some fantastic reading. Some insightful, some hilarious: "Steak tartare was not invented by Mongol warriors who tenderized meat under their saddles."
- smogcutter 6y agoMaybe a confusion of tartar the sauce with Tatars the central Asian nomads? There’s possibly something there though, even if the steak tartar version is incorrect. Bret Deveraux claims the aim was to preserve meat into a kind of jerky: “On the move, meat could be placed between the rider’s saddle and the horse’s back – the frequent compression of riding, combined with the salinity of the horse’s sweat would produce a dried, salted jerky that would keep for a very long time.”[1] His stuff is very well sourced, but also he’s self-admittedly talking outside his area of expertise there. So who knows. [1] https://acoup.blog/2020/12/11/collections-that-dothraki-horde-part-ii-subsistence-on-the-hoof/ https://acoup.blog/2020/12/11/collections-that-dothraki-hord...
- andredz 6y agoThis is the first time I hear of this (https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/). I had always assumed they had the same etymology. It didn't help that in Spanish all of these words maintain the 'r' between the 'a' and 't': tártaro, ra, Tártaro, Tartaria. Here there are 3 different etymologies: https://dle.rae.es/t%C3%A1rtaro https://dle.rae.es/t%C3%A1rtaro and here there's another one: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sauce_tartare https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sauce_tartare Although I don't know if the Wikipedia article should be trusted, since the English version one (Tartar sauce) states: "The word Tartar is a Turkic word that is the name of Tatar people."
- bb123 6y agoJust because it isn't surprising doesn't mean it isn't interesting.
- polycaster 6y agoNo, it doesn't. But it is very likely that one thing comes from the other. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interest_(emotion) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interest_(emotion)
- datameta 6y agoPerhaps for some here (including myself) this data helps imagine a more detailed approximation of what life was like there in that time period.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoI don't think that this quote is what the article boils down to. IMHO the key information is rather: ""However, severe trauma was prevalent across the social spectrum." At all levels they found a significant number of skeletons with bone fractures.
- sandworm101 6y agoYes, the injury rate may be similar, but the sources of these injuries are likely not. Amongst the ruling classes, horses were the danger. Ride a horse and you will break more bones than the guy who walks to work. Be a friar working in a hospital, not toiling in the fields nor riding horses, and your fracture rate would be much lower.
- wpasc 6y agoBut your risk of bacterial infection probably skyrockets
- ashtonkem 6y agoAlso violence, but in different forms. For lower classes, regular street brawls will produce a lot of injuries. Upper class people will get into some street violence, but the presence of retinues will drastically reduce their incidence. On the other hand, for upper classes (but not monks) war and training for war will produce a ton of injuries, many fatal. Learning to fence and joust are very dangerous activities even in modern times.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> Learning to fence and joust are very dangerous activities even in modern times. Horses. Even today, horses are profoundly dangerous. Go to any hospital warn dealing with neck injuries. Young men fall off motorcycles, and so are generally a little older (16+). Young girls break their necks falling off horses. That particular fall (head first off a horse) is horrible. The neck takes all the load. Helmets protect the skull, not the neck. Obama once said that if he had sons there would be a conversation about them playing football. If I had daughters, they would not ride horses.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Somehow I fail to see how this is surprising. Validating assumptions is useful science.
- pasquinelli 6y agoyeah, but it's also been published on the bbc and posted here.
- beckman466 6y ago> Somehow I fail to see how this is surprising. Yes! who cares about the lives of such lowly peasants. /s
- dang 6y ago"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- shadowprofile77 6y agoCan't say much for hospital inmates but, bear in mind that friars in medieval Europe often had their days filled with plenty of hard physical labour as well, and often tended to farm plots for the benefit of their monasteries and church lands with lots of their own sweaty work. It was not what we would today consider a sedentary job at all. Though yes, a labourer would have been much more likely to suffer injuries regardless... One good fictional account of medieval life among all classes: Pillars of the Earth, by Ken Follet. Wonderful reading and realistically depicted in most ways.
- dang 6y ago"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 99_00 6y agoWhat did you think the % of bone fractures would be before you read the article?
- bb123 6y agoI for found the gender difference quite surprising. I would not have imagined at the bottom levels of an agrarian society that there was much difference in the risks men and women faced.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> I for found the gender difference quite surprising. I'm not sure what you're referring to. Could you provide the relevant quote?
- rtkwe 6y ago^F "male" > Across all sites the team found fractures were more common in male remains (40%) than female (26%)
- InitialLastName 6y agoI wonder how that ratio compares to now. I would assume that men (especially teenage/young adult men) are still more likely to suffer injuries (due to higher risk tolerance/attraction, in addition to continued workplace differences).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- laurent92 6y agoMen are ~93% of workplace fatality in XXIst century, both in USA and France for which I’ve seen the figures, although it’s only 450 deaths in France. It is on upwards trend for women (very recent trend, probably equalization of work) and downwards trend for men (has been on the decrease since WWII).
- InitialLastName 6y agoSpecifically, I'm interested in what proportion of people have (at the point of death) had a bone fracture at some point. I would assume that workplace fatality has been dropping (in line with ~all other forms of non-age-related fatality), but a look back through my mind-palace of anecdotal evidence suggests that a) more of the young men I knew than young women have broken bones and b) not far off 30% of the people I know, in (roughly speaking) the most economically privileged class in world history have broken bones at some point. What I'm curious about is the data to back up the anecdote.
- gherkinnn 6y agoTook me a while to find the referenced paper [0]. Way more detail (of course) but also accessible. 0 - https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ajpa.24225 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ajpa.24225
- gherkinnn 6y agoInterested in how common broken bones are today, I stumbled across this study: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12111017/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12111017/ > There were 6451 men and 6936 women followed for a median of 3.0 years. During this time there were 140 incident limb fractures in men and 391 in women. Whereas OP's archaeological study had: > Fractures were more prevalent in males (40%, n = 57/143) than females (26%, n = 25/95).
- radu_floricica 6y agoAge, maybe? Primary cause for fractures nowadays is osteoporosis, which AFAIK is more serious to women after menopause. Primary cause historically was accidents, with the opposite distribution.
- greatpatton 6y agoSport? I mean almost all the people I know had a broken bone or joint issue because of sport and then you have domestic accident. For instance in Switzerland each year you have 550k non-professional accident (declared one to your employer) for 8.5M inhabitants. (Ref: SUVA annual report but only available in GE and FR)
- hammock 6y agoWhy is osteoporosis so prevalent in modern age? Diet?
- nickff 6y agoOsteoporosis is (largely) an old person's disease, and people are now living long enough to get it.
- jandrese 6y agoPeople just live longer.
- stan_rogers 6y agoThat, and like many cancers, just a larger number of people living long enough to fall victim to it. Women developing what are usually postmenopausal issues more or less requires living to and through menopause. (Yes, old people got to be nearly as old as they do now, but getting to be old was much less of a sure thing.)
- tkahnoski 6y agoIn reading about this, my first thought was... in 300 years will they be digging up our current cemeteries? The answer is a resounding 'very possible'. Although there are federal laws on the books https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaeological_ethics#Preservation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaeological_ethics#Preserva... There was a modern attempt at relocating a cemetery in 1988 that ultimately failed for political reasons: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eloise_Cemetery#Present_situation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eloise_Cemetery#Present_situat... And there are things like this in the Texas State Code that give clearance for eminent domain actions: https://casetext.com/statute/texas-codes/water-code/title-4-general-law-districts/chapter-49-provisions-applicable-to-all-districts/subchapter-h-powers-and-duties/section-49224-power-to-condemn-cemeteries https://casetext.com/statute/texas-codes/water-code/title-4-... So don't buy a plot in a prospective dam/reservoir area in Texas if you want to be undisturbed for centuries.
- laurent92 6y agoIn France, burial « concessions » are 10 years renewable to 30 years. I’m not sure what options are in case your family wants to keep your grave longer. Is it indefinite duration in USA?
- tkahnoski 6y agoI personally have no idea. US culture is rather averse to discussing matters of death so this is all new. My brief searching around looks like this is tied to however you purchase the plot and the terms set with the cemetery itself and if they expire, they just bury someone a foot or two above the previous plot owner after removing the headstone....
- retrac 6y agoAt least here in Ontario, Canada, cemetery plots are infinite duration, and the land is classified for that purpose forever. There are plenty of little cemetery plots attached to old 19th century churches in downtown Toronto, now surrounded by skyscrapers. I think it's the same in the USA.
- Larrikin 6y ago
- beckman466 6y agoYou hear that Uber eats riders? you peasants, you! You too can make the news in just under 1,000 years, after you've fallen into a swamp (with your body staying preserved), after splitting your head on a rock, after going 30mph around a corner with an about-to-blow tire and a huge 8-person 'late' order in your painfully overburdened backpack, and lastly, after having been exhausted and worn out from the consecutive 60-hour weeks you've been making as a 'freelancer'... /s
- libraryatnight 6y agoOr just disappear while trying to find a place to pee. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25983785 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25983785