4 ms·
This has been a fear since the earliest days of online communities. I don't think actual behavior has confirmed that it occurs more often online than elsewhere;
by gojomo 15y ago
This has been a fear since the earliest days of online communities. I don't think actual behavior has confirmed that it occurs more often online than elsewhere; if it did, Pariser would have more hard data (rather than just-so anecdotes and hand-wringing about potential-risks) by this time.
People who want to be insulated could always achieve it; however people also like novelty and (to a certain extent) challenges to their own views. (People even enjoy being outraged; I suspect right-wing-radio has as many listeners thinking 'ohmygod what an idiot' as 'finally someone who tells it like it is'.)
Online forums make it cheaper, easier, and even socially safer to incrementally explore alternative viewpoints without precommitting, via a public show of group-loyalty, to a standard school of thought.
I suspect the net effect is strongly in the direction of more awareness and respect for a wide variety of viewpoints, despite the sturm and drang of certain flamefests and partisan outlets. (And even despite the success of Pariser's own organization MoveOn, and its siblings across the political spectrum, with simpleminded outrage-driven us-vs-them fundraising campaigns.)
However, I'd like to see data or a well-designed experiment; none of the coverage of Pariser's book has yet suggested a qualitatively-rigorous case is made within.