4 ms·
Remember the Hertz story in June? They were thinking about issuing shares. I dunno, it seems like meme stocks are in that position because they're small-cap co
by dehrmann 6y ago
Remember the Hertz story in June? They were thinking about issuing shares.
I dunno, it seems like meme stocks are in that position because they're small-cap companies facing significant headwinds and either got overshorted or have enough brand recognition that retail investors seem convinced they'll survive. I'd rather not be in the position of facing the headwinds and hoping a bunch of suckers show up who will give me money.
What's funny is this is pointing out big holes in the "but it's 150% shorted" story. The retail buy/sell order flow seemed pretty balanced on Thursday according to Citadel, so there isn't much HODL. If the price holds for much longer, Gamestop can issue more shares, and holders of convertable debt are converting, likely selling the shares ASAP.
I guess they squeezed some shorts, some more shorts probably moved in, and some of the money goes to debt holders, and some might go to the company. Some of it makes for a good story, but I wouldn't be surprised if PE and hedge funds quietly come out ahead in aggregate.
- xwdv 6y agoI would love to see how irrational the market can get. I think we will see the limits of what is possible pushed in this century. I’m bullish!
- rsynnott 6y agoOh, they weren't just THINKING about it: https://www.wsj.com/articles/hertz-sold-29-million-in-stock-before-sec-stepped-in-11597100128 https://www.wsj.com/articles/hertz-sold-29-million-in-stock-...
- dehrmann 6y ago(not sarcastic) Good for them!
- snomad 6y ago> What's funny is this is pointing out big holes in the "but it's 150% shorted" story. Not sure I follow. The hedge funds are shorting the stock, debt holders are converting to stock, Retail (and plenty of big players) are buying and holding. 3 different parties.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe "150% shorted" narrative has been deliberately misrepresented. WSB wants everyone to think that there are 150% short positions and only 100% long positions. In reality, each short creates a synthetic long, so there are always more long positions than short positions. WSB also seems to misunderstand the short interest. They're pushing the idea that short interest must start going down to indicate the squeeze has started. They're not accounting for (or deliberately ignoring) the fact that new short positions can be initiated at $360 which will be profitable when the stock inevitably falls. Reddit can't keep the stock high forever with a never-ending stream of buyers. That's why they've now shifted to pushing the narrative that everyone should buy and hold $GME to hurt Wall Street, which isn't really true either. WSB is also pushing the narrative that everyone is holding (or hodling) $GME shares and refusing to sell. This is perhaps the strangest claim of all, since it's so easily debunked by looking at the huge daily volume of shares traded. Shares can't be traded unless a buyer and seller agree on a price. The volume is extremely high, which means plenty of people are selling their $GME all day every day. WallStreetBets has devolved into a blatant pump-and-dump megaphone.
- adenadel 6y agoNot trying to say you're wrong, but what's the typical short borrow fee? Isn't the WSB argument that if the price stays high long enough, the shorts will have to exit their position rather than pay their fees? Also, can anyone explain to me why there are so many short positions rather than just buying puts?
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoRealistically, WSB can only rally the general public to pour money into $GME for so long before people get tired of being used to prop up a stock. It will come back down. Short squeezes are short, temporary events. Even with borrow fees in the range of 30-50% (per year), it's a small price to pay for a short-term play. It's not realistic to expect the general public to continue pouring money into Gamestop stock to keep the price propped up. Keep in mind that shorts can also exit and re-enter their short positions with high frequency. Not all of the shorting activity is long-term shorting that started <$10 And of course, the original Melvin Capital claims to have exited their original short position. WSB wants us to believe they're lying, but I'm inclined to believe them.
- plorkyeran 6y agoThe SEC stopped Hertz from issuing shares because the prospectus was basically "even with this infusion of cash we're going to go bankrupt and you'll lose all your money." The ideal meme stock would be one where the company has short-term cashflow problems and so is heavily shorted by investors expecting it to go bankrupt, but which aren't actually just doomed money pits.
- jjeaff 6y agoGamestop is actually profitable. Their stock has taken a hit because people believe there is little future. But its financial situation is not nearly as dire as Hertz or other highly leveraged companies.