4 ms·
I think intellectual property should be taxed as are other properties and assets. This would seem to have the nice side effect of setting a monetary value in IP
by kstrauser 6y ago
I think intellectual property should be taxed as are other properties and assets. This would seem to have the nice side effect of setting a monetary value in IP lawsuits. If you declare that your property is worth $X when you file taxes, you couldn’t really argue that it’s worth $10X when suing over violations of it.
And frankly, I think IP should be taxed since holders rely on the government to protect it. If I have a house, it’s at least hypothetically possible that I can defend it myself. That’s not possible with intellectual property. So if holders are relying on that government to uphold its value, they should be expected to contribute proportionally to that value for the service.
- frongpik 6y agoThat's really clever to tie taxes to the declared scope of IP rights. Would be good to get this idea seen by Sanders. RIAA would do just about anything to stop this law. Right now they claim that a downloaded song (without their permission) or a movie makes them lose 10k usd a some fantasy amount in that range. But then IRS could multiply this amount by the number of songs they own and demand 2% - in line with property taxes. Better 3%, since IP rights, unlike houses, are active assets that bring royalties.
- sriku 6y agoIsn't it the case that the use of IP generates wealth which is taxed anyway? So wouldn't that amount to a kind of double taxation?
- haakonhr 6y agoDouble taxation is completely normal. You pay taxes on dividends, which have been taxed as company earnings already. In many places you pay a tax on real estate and other assets, which you of course bought with (presumably) already. Inheritance taxes are another example.
- grishka 6y agoIf you own a house and rent it to someone, you would pay both the property tax on the house itself and the income tax on the rent. Seems normal to me.
- sriku 6y agoThe comparison seems fair .. in the sense that property tax serves to cover the cost to society of the property existing, just as "IP tax" would be to cover the cost to society of protecting the "IP". Looks like such a tax would also separate the concern of protection, from the concern of exploitation of the IP. But I can't imagine how one would tax created IP .. at least in property, there is some sense of "market value", which is anybody's guess when it comes to IP. edit: Maybe IP can be assigned "shares" in wealth injected into the market?
- grishka 6y agoThere is "market value" of IP in the sense that there are prices consumers are supposed to pay for it. The price of a movie ticket, the price of a music album, the price of a video game. The tax can be calculated based on that and the popularity of the creative work in question.
- jgeada 6y agoMy salary is taxed. And yet when I spend it, it becomes someone else's salary, and theirs is taxed too. How come the silly "double taxation" meme is only brought up when we're talking about rich people's money? (ie corporations, rent-seeking structures, etc)
- grishka 6y agoAnd make that taxation progressive so it would be unprofitable to hold on to copyrights for decades. This feels even better than my idea about making copyright very short, on the order of several years — technically it would be indefinite, but only if you can pay the ever-increasing cost to maintain it. The IP tax would also solve the status of abandonware once and for all — the company is no longer around to pay the tax on its copyright, so the copyright gets terminated and the works become public domain.
- anilgulecha 6y agoYour comment is a once-in-a-while one of incredible insight. Indeed, this seems a great way of framing the cost of applying copyright laws in society.