5 ms·
"Thus it is in a simple substance, and not in a compound or in a machine, that perception must be sought for" This is an incorrect conclusion. You can inspect
by adrianN 15y ago
"Thus it is in a simple substance, and not in a compound or in a machine, that perception must be sought for"
This is an incorrect conclusion. You can inspect individual grains of sand as long as you want, you will never find a beach. Yet beaches are composed of sand with no magic involved.
- brudgers 15y agoOn the other hand a beach also is part of a shoreline, and thus you will not find a beach at Great Sand Dunes National Park http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Sand_Dunes_National_Park_and_Preserve http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Sand_Dunes_National_Park_...
- ugh 15y agoWhat’s your point?
- brudgers 15y agoBy "beach" we don't mean "many grains of sand." The parent analogy using grains does no more gets us a beach than using gears and pulleys or RAM and CPU's gets us a brain.
- ugh 15y agoWe mean many grains of sand in a certain configuration which are also in close proximity to many molecules of water in a certain configuration†. Do you really argue that beaches have some sort of, well, “magic”, I guess, property which makes them a beach? That seems entirely unnecessary for something as simple as beaches. You can map all the grains of sand, you can map all the molecules of water and confidently identify when something is a beach. We know how to explain beaches in terms of grains of sands and molecules of water. We cannot yet explain all properties of brains (most notably consciousness) in terms of, say, neurons but just because we cannot yet doesn’t mean we never will. †What those configurations are depends entirely on your definition of “beach”. Sand or water might also no play a role at all, again, depending on your definition.
- lists 15y ago>Do you really argue that beaches have some sort of, well, “magic”, I guess, property which makes them a beach? That seems entirely unnecessary for something as simple as beaches. And yet your caveat at the bottom illustrates that what a beach is isn't a trivial problem. Leibniz just wanted to avoid the regressive mechanical discussion by positing substances or monads as a solution to answering the question "What's a beach?". This isn't to say he's right than to say your trivialization doesn't work and that there's room for his speculation.
- ugh 15y agoNo, that’s just my standard “definitions are boring, let’s just agree to not discuss them”-disclaimer. Ah, well. Definitions don’t make the problem hard. There is just no one true definition of beach, that’s fine. We can agree to use the one most commonly used or you can pick one, it doesn’t matter as long as we communicate the definition we are using. I again and again find it astonishing that so many people have problems understanding what definitions are all about. They are about communication. Arguing about definitions is rather pointless, at least if you goal is to learn something about the world. (Good definitions make communication easier so there is room for argument about definitions but not really in this case.)
- lists 15y agoI'm not trying to defend Leibniz' argument so much as point out the space in which he can make it. I think that you may be confusing the two in responding to me as, let's be clear, Leibniz is writing in an utterly distinct intellectual environment from us. The pragmatism of communication as a standard for assessing representations does not exist in the 17th century as human cognition is still being assessed in relation to a possibility of omniscience that sometimes goes by the name of God. Communication, or inter-subjective experience, only becomes a standard after Kant. So monads or Leibniz' way of talking about substances is a way to negotiate the unique problems of conscious perception in relation to that possibility of omniscience.
- brudgers 15y ago