5 ms·
The only difference between a UBI and a negative income tax is framing. Suppose you have a negative income tax in the amount of $12,000 which phases out at a r
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
The only difference between a UBI and a negative income tax is framing.
Suppose you have a negative income tax in the amount of $12,000 which phases out at a rate of 25% up to $48,000 in income, and a 5% marginal tax rate on people who make less than $48,000 and a 30% marginal tax rate on people who make more.
Suppose you have a $12,000 UBI and a flat 30% tax rate.
These are really the same thing. The advantage of the UBI is that you see more clearly what you're doing, so that if somebody suggests to e.g. have a steeper phase out, what it really corresponds to is having a higher marginal tax rate on lower income people than higher income people. Which is maybe not what you want.
- randomdata 6y agoIsn't the practical difference the past vs. the future? A negative income tax is based on already reported income, whereas UBI is clawed back once income is reported.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThis is equivalent to whether the UBI is paid on the first day of the period or the last day of the period and is only a meaningful distinction in the first period of implementation.
- randomdata 6y agoTo wrap my head around this, let's assume the period is the calendar year. Let's assume that I made enough from January to March that I exceed a payout position under a negative income tax system, but COVID-19 saw me lose my job in March and my income dried up since then. When I report my income as of December 31st, 2020, I still made enough for the year that I won't receive benefits, despite not having an income. That means that I will be unsupported through 2021 and won't see the money until 2022, correct? If it were UBI and I were paid on January 1st 2020, it would be clawed back on December 31st as I still made enough money, but I would receive another payment on January 1st 2021 to get me through the year where I have no income. Isn't that the intent of UBI and not something afforded through negative income? You could pay out a UBI-like stipend and then claw it back on the same day (December 31st, 2020), but is it really UBI at that point? That sounds like the negative income tax.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> When I report my income as of December 31st, 2020, I still made enough for the year that I won't receive benefits, despite not having an income. That means that I will be unsupported through 2021 and won't see the money until 2022, correct? There is no "don't receive benefits" anywhere. Everybody gets $12,000/year every year in both cases. Then separately people who make more than $48,000/year pay more than a total of $12,000/year in taxes or phase outs.
- randomdata 6y ago> There is no "don't receive benefits" anywhere. Everybody gets $12,000/year in both cases. Does a negative income tax not tell that high earners pay money to the state, while low earners receive money from the state? If everyone receives money from the state, even if high earners have to pay it back at tax time, that does not meet the definition of negative income tax as I know it. That is UBI. A more concrete example would be useful.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoYou don't pay income tax at tax time, it gets withheld from your paycheck on an ongoing basis. Suppose you make $20,000/month, i.e. $240,000/year if you made that the whole year. In January through March you make $20,000/month. Under a UBI you receive $1000 but then pay $6000 in taxes, a net payment to the government of $5000/month. Under a negative income tax you pay 5% on the first $4000 ($200) and 30% on the remaining $16,000 ($4800), and expect to receive no credit because it fully phased out, so a net payment to the government of $5000/month. It's the same. In April through December you make nothing. Then you get the $1000 UBI/credit and there is no tax. To receive the net money from the tax credit before the end of the year you would have to be able to claim it without a job, and to set your withholding amount to a negative number that month because you have no income. Which is theoretically possible (it would be what happens to anyone making <$48,000/year), and either way you still get the same total amount at the end of the year when you file your taxes and reconcile.
- 6y ago
- hehehaha 6y agoWith UBI, people will be more selective in their job search. With negative tax rate not so much since you would need to work in order to benefit. I am not a fan of them because they will simply push out cost of living and the poor will be back in same relative economic disadvantage. The only realistic solution I see is free education even into adult age.
- bhupy 6y agoI'd argue that this is a feature, and not a bug. It gives the lower-income worker leverage to walk away from a bad job without fear of starvation.
- RangerScience 6y agoYup. If all jobs have to compete with the null-job, then there will be no jobs worse than just getting up to your own devices.
- andrewflnr 6y agoAbsolutely, this is one of the most important reasons to have it IMO.
- maxerickson 6y agoI don't think people talking about a negative income tax are aligned behind it being non refundable.
- akvadrako 6y ago> With negative tax rate not so much since you would need to work in order to benefit This is not how NIT works. You can read this for an intro: https://www.scottsantens.com/negative-income-tax-nit-and-unconditional-basic-income-ubi-what-makes-them-the-same-and-what-makes-them-different https://www.scottsantens.com/negative-income-tax-nit-and-unc...
- hehehaha 6y agoYou still need to work and have income. If I am missing something I’d love to know.
- RangerScience 6y agoIsn't the another significant different in the logistics of distribution? For UBI, you need to / get to have a direct line to every person/citizen. For NI, they come to you. I honestly have no idea which one is better/easier from this perspective, it just seems like the logistics implementation is another significant difference.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoI don't know if I would call that a significant difference, especially since neither one of them is really tied to any specific logistical approach. You could pay a UBI as net of withholding so that it comes once a year in the same check as your tax refund. You could pay a negative income tax on a weekly basis so that net recipients get a tax refund check every week.
- cactus2093 6y agoIt seems like either one could work much the same way in terms of ease of distribution, but I agree UBI sounds simpler and more direct. Maybe just because it's something new and it's straightforward in principle so we can fantasize about it actually working efficiently. I imagine UBI as a system where every citizen gets a monthly check, no questions asked. It shows up in the mail or gets direct deposited and that's it. And if someone can't receive it that way, say if they're homeless or don't have a bank account, maybe there could even be a place they can show up and collect their money in person. This might still be a pipe dream but it doesn't seem impossible, the hard part is actually figuring out how to pay for a UBI program. Contrast that to sticking it into the existing income tax system. I imagine that would mean you'd only collect the money annually, and only if you file a tax return. Lots of people without much income don't file tax returns so that's already a blocker. And once the money is gone, a year is a long time to wait for another payment. Of course there's no reason a negative income tax couldn't still be distributed monthly and made more easily acceptable, but there's just a lot of baggage around the thought of dealing with taxes.
- robocat 6y ago> The only difference between a UBI and a negative income tax is framing. No way. Taxation requires benefit systems for those that are not working (unemployment, disability, maternity etc). UBI simplifies benefit systems, administratively and for the needy. The social outcomes for benefits are entirely different from what a UBI would bring. Taxation is chunky (per year) and delayed (processing delays). There are heaps of corner cases of employment and salary changes during the year that might be equivalent over periods of many many months, but where a weekly UBI payment would make a huge difference to you if you were poor or unfortunate. Taxation has more scope for fraud so requires much more overhead for prevention. A UBI is simple to manage - the things you need to detect are far more limited and are more easily checked and less invasively checked. Disclaimer: I am not a UBI fan: I am just arguing against your point because it is so egregiously incorrect.
- 6510 6y agoYes, you could have a smaller overhead with a large amount of fraud and a lot of exclusion of people in need but you can also have an enormous overhead, still have some fraud and still exclude some of those who need it the most. End of the day you cant measure need. If you have 2 people with migraine, back pain and some problem in their social lives there is no way to calculate or compare their situation fairly. (both are better than what we have)
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Taxation requires benefit systems for those that are not working (unemployment, disability, maternity etc). Not a negative income tax, for exactly the same reason that a UBI doesn't, because they're the same thing. > Taxation is chunky (per year) and delayed (processing delays). Neither of these is inherently different. You could have a per-year UBI with processing delays. You could have an instantaneous tax reconciliation system with electronic transfers. > Taxation has more scope for fraud so requires much more overhead for prevention. You say that as if the existence of a UBI would cause there to not be taxation. Having a negative income tax is entirely orthogonal to tax complexity. The explanation is more complicated, because it's just a harder to reason about way of describing the same system.
- jpindar 6y agoYou can't buy food with a printout that says you're going to get some money next year.