4 ms·
> Horses for courses. Is anyone suggesting QUIC for gigantic bulk transfers? Anyone who's looking to replace HTTP/1.1 and HTTP/2 with HTTP/3? AFAIK QUIC is com
by masklinn 6y ago
> Horses for courses. Is anyone suggesting QUIC for gigantic bulk transfers?
Anyone who's looking to replace HTTP/1.1 and HTTP/2 with HTTP/3? AFAIK QUIC is completely integral to that, in order to avoid this issue you'll need a mixed deployment of HTTP/3 and an older version of the standard.
- anderspitman 6y agoI just hope we don't remove support for HTTP/1.1 from our stacks entirely. 2/3 are great for performance but an order of magnitude more complex.
- M2Ys4U 6y agoI imagine that HTTP/2 use will almost entirely move to HTTP/3, and HTTP/1.1 usage will decline but there'll still be plenty of it around.
- cpeterso 6y agoCloudflare’s Radar dashboard has recent measurements of HTTP/1, 2, and 3 traffic (near the bottom of the page): https://radar.cloudflare.com/ https://radar.cloudflare.com/ Right now, HTTP/1.x is 23% of traffic, HTTP/2 is 75%, and HTTP/3 is just 2%. Since this is about overall traffic (visible to Cloudflare), big sites like Google and Facebook dominate. All that HTTP/3 traffic is probably Chrome users watching YouTube.
- jeffbee 6y agoI’m positive that an organization the size of Netflix which has dedicated itself absolutely to pushing 200gbps out of every individual box can figure out how to run HTTP 1.1 forever.
- otabdeveloper4 6y ago"Whee, the magic number went up, better upgrade". Despite Google meddling with the standards, "HTTP/3" isn't HTTP.
- chrismorgan 6y ago> Despite Google meddling with the standards Please let that misconception die. I’m not at all fond of Google, but HTTP/3 is not a Google thing: Google is just one (admittedly significant) party involved in making a thing that lots of parties want and have worked together to make. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25286488 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25286488 is a relevant comment I wrote a couple of months ago.
- otabdeveloper4 6y ago> ...a thing that lots of parties want and have worked together to make So, a) what parties? b) what exactly did they contribute? Look, yeah, it's a good thing that standards still exist and Google has to play social engineering games instead of suddenly dropping this stuff on us as a fait accompli. But let's not pretend like Google doesn't own the Internet; it'll save us grief and tears in the future if we see things clearly as they are.
- chrismorgan 6y agoIt’s all on public record; take a look in the relevant IETF working group. There are quite a large number of parties that have made meaningful contributions, and I’m too lazy to find and enumerate any. And in line with my linked comment, Google engineers want those contributions, as the end result of such collaboration is consistently significantly superior to what was developed by one party alone. Google is not strong-arming IETF into doing things. There’s widespread (though certainly not universal) consensus that QUIC or an equivalent is a worthy goal, and worth collaborating on to achieve that end. Look, I wanted something like QUIC before they produced it, because HTTP/2 was better than HTTP/1.1 in most ways, but had the critical TCP HOLB problem that makes it markedly worse than HTTP/1.1 in some situations—and something like QUIC is the only way of fixing that, since the SCTP approach is no longer socially viable. (And before that, I had long wanted something like HTTP/2, because the limitations of HTTP/1.1 were sometimes rather frustrating. —Though I must confess that I wasn’t immediately taken with SPDY and the particular way Google pushed it initially.) Google doesn’t own the internet. Let it go. Yes, they have an unhealthily large influence on consumer matters—but also nowhere near as large in infrastructural. Google were the ones to advance the initial SPDY and QUIC proposals because their position as massive server operators and manufacturers of a popular browser meant that they were simply the company best-suited to making such initial development (and sure, it served their interests well too).