4 ms·
This is good. Too long have universities maintained the illusion that all subjects are worth studying. They are not. And we have a valuation mechanism - pay. Th
by renewiltord 6y ago
This is good. Too long have universities maintained the illusion that all subjects are worth studying. They are not. And we have a valuation mechanism - pay. The truth is that some subjects need far fewer participants than others. You don’t need the marginal new mathematician or historian or geographer.
We do need the marginal electrical engineer or software engineer. It is crucial that we signal to students their prospects accurately and operate our collective learning facilities in the interest of the public.
The number of support staff required to service a bug organization does grow super linearly which is a reason to have smaller universities. These institutions suffer massive diseconomies of scale past a certain size as information transfer suffers.
Unfortunately, support staff grow more support staff at a higher rate than productive staff so it is necessary to keep university size small.
But of course, Tim Gowers is a bit of a luminary, so maybe I’m entirely wrong on all of this.
- rscho 6y agoThat has to be the most capitalistic opinion I've read in a long time. This is in essence: "let's just limit access to studies yielding no current or short-term anticipated industrial benefit to rich people". This is what monetary valuation means. What do you make of studies potentially yielding long-term benefits? Yeah, nothing. This is depressing.
- ssivark 6y agoWhere would you rank the marginal university administrator?
- renewiltord 6y agoProbably not very useful. The problem we have is that support staff units are in control of staff expansion. They then create more support staff out of some institutional reproductive urge. It is a flaw in The Firm.
- daniel-thompson 6y agoThis is classic short-term MBA thinking. It completely misses that theoretical researchers are an integral part of a diverse research ecosystem, that researcher diversity is more than the sum of its parts (or in MBA-speak, is synergistic), that some theoretical work eventually does become economically valuable as it filters into applied sciences, and that this might take longer than one or two quarters after publication.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoYou are entirely wrong on this. Mathematics and logic are the core of science.
- mbrodersen 6y agoAll modern technologies (including the internet) came out of not-for-profit research done at Universities. Private companies are great at exploring already existing markets but really bad at creating new ones. You need long term blue sky research to discover markets that nobody with a short term profit motive would even think about.