6 ms·
It's really a shame the Chevy Volt didn't dominate like the Tesla. It's the perfect transition vehicle. I had a Smart Fortwo which was cute but had terrible ran
by endisneigh 6y ago
It's really a shame the Chevy Volt didn't dominate like the Tesla. It's the perfect transition vehicle. I had a Smart Fortwo which was cute but had terrible range - followed by the Nissan Leaf which was better but had terrible battery life in the winter which has only been resolved recently.
Tesla Model 3's are nice, but if you're an economical driver the cost per mile is still way higher than a hybrid. Ugh.
EDIT: To clarify I'm referring to the total cost per mile, not just the cost to drive a mile - the Model 3 wins in that regard as far as I know. The problem is that the Model 3 costs tens of thousands of dollars more than the cheapest hybrids, so unless you're going to keep your Model 3 for like 300K miles it's not worth it on a purely economical basis.
If you compare to a gas car, again on a purely economical basis, it's even more lopsided. Factor in used vehicles and even more so. I ended up just buying a used Corolla in the end sadly since it was cheaper and from my understanding more environmentally friendly.
TLDR: If you want to be "environmentally friendly" that means minimizing driving. However, if you minimize driving it makes basically no sense, economically or environmentally to buy an electric car - you're better off buying a fuel efficient used vehicle. Please correct me if you believe I'm wrong in this thinking.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoHow is the cost per mile higher in a Model 3 than a hybrid? As far as I know the model 3 is basically the most energy efficient EV on the market, in terms of KWh per mile. The Model 3 is lighter, more aerodynamic, and has more efficient motors.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThe parent has edited their comment, but the issue is that the sticker price on the Model 3 is still too high— you need to drive it for a super long time/distance to recoup those costs.
- djrogers 6y agoOr sell it. Resale value in Tesla’s is quite high compared to a Volt.
- rootusrootus 6y agoApparent resale value, perhaps -- that is, what people ask for them. What they actually sell for is a different story. I am trying to sell my Model 3 Performance right now. After owning it for just over a year. It seems to have depreciated about a thousand bucks a month.
- mikepurvis 6y agoWell and who knows what they'll be worth in four to five years, particularly as battery tech continues to improve.
- symlinkk 6y agoInteresting, why are you selling so soon?
- rootusrootus 6y agoI replied to another person who asked the same question. TL;DR: Reasons, none of which have to do with disliking the car.
- cptskippy 6y agoWhy are you selling?
- rootusrootus 6y agoPartly because I'm a car spaz (I seem to buy a different one every couple years), and partly because I'm now fully remote with no expectation of going back to commuting, so I'm barely driving 50-100 miles a month. Having a nearly 60K car sitting in the garage doing nothing but depreciating is not a great plan. It's my third car, I don't really need it in any case.
- danans 6y agoIt's definitely possible. It just depends on local gas and electricity prices. For example, in CA current regular grade fuel is about $3.40/gal. A Prius gets 60mpg, which works out to 6c/mile. For electricity, the average rate in CA is 24c/kWh. A model 3 uses 250 Wh/mile which works out to 6c/mile. So exactly the same price per mile. A small change in either fuel price could advantage one or the other. Of course you can take advantage of overnight lower EV charging rates, or drive to an area with cheaper gas, but at least with current average energy prices, there isn't a huge difference in per mile energy consumption costs.
- rootusrootus 6y agoThe base Model 3 or the SR+ (probably) are pretty efficient. But the dual motors are a bit more thirsty. My wife's Bolt weighs 500 pounds less and gets substantially better economy from every kWh than my Model 3 Performance does. Whether I drive like a jerk or not.
- Faaak 6y agoThe tesla model 3 is 15kWh/100km, mucho more than the Hyundai ioniq 11kWh/100km.
- m463 6y agoI always thought of the volt as twice the complexity, twice the responsibility. You still have to keep track and change the oil, and the coolant. You still have a water pump and spark plugs and all this other stuff to keep track of. AND you have all the EV worries like the battery.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI've never had a vehicle that required less maintenance than my 2017 Volt. Up to 100k KM on it now and I've changed the oil once + tire swaps and some rust removal on the brakes because they don't get much use due to regen. That's all. But 88% of my travel is pure electric, so. The ICE only needs as much maintenance as you use it for.
- endisneigh 6y agoIt's true that the Volt does have a lot of complexity - however you also have access to the existing infrastructure for gas cars.
- m463 6y agoMy solution was a leaf and a gas vehicle (which pretty much went unused)
- fencepost 6y agoI do suspect that the ICE portion of the Volt could be a lot simpler than a regular gas powered vehicle since it's not directly connected to the wheels. A generator configured to run primarily with a fixed load size and in its peak efficiency zone is different from what you find in the typical gas car.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIn Gen2 Volt it is actually connected to the wheels in some modes. It's not a series hybrid. But its maintenance is very low. Very little wear on it.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThis is the barrier for me too— my family lives in a walkable, downtown community and our overall driving is 5-10k km/yr. It would be fun to have an EV, but from both a $$ and eco point of view, I think if you're already committed to a low car lifestyle, your best option for some time yet is to carry on buying lower-efficiency vehicles that are at least 4 years old. This prevents an existing vehicle (for which the carbon cost to manufacture it is sunk) from being abandoned, but using it as a backup vehicle means it won't be driven more than a minimum, and having your gas be "expensive" on a per-km basis creates the proper incentives to avoid driving except where necessary.
- emj 6y agoJust commit and sell the car, our driving was about double that and we do not miss it a bit now. Still drive about 1000 km/year in rentals, but we are trying to minimize that.. It's especially nice as a family to primarly transport yourself in other ways were you get to spend time together interacting freely instead of being stuck in a car. Economically it's more or less the same, but a better quality of life.
- mikepurvis 6y agoWe've thought about it. One of the main barriers is honestly the combo of a) out of town family and b) young children. Installing carseats and boosters in a rental is a giant pain, and the train/coach schedules aren't dense enough to permit a reliable day trip to a location that's a 60-90 minute drive away. We do have another family in our circle are are carfree and they make it work with a combination of rentals and every now and then they borrow our car in exchange for babysitting and other favours.
- olau 6y agoDepends on the seats. We have seats that you just put in. They are held in place by the seatbelt. So there's a bit of extra carrying the seats, that's all. We bought them because they were top scoring in a crash safety test.
- fallingknife 6y agoElectric engines are much simpler and should last a lot longer than ICE, so that extra upfront cost will be divided over a lot more miles, and there will be a lot less maintenance expense.
- carlmr 6y agoThe motor yes, but a gas tank lasts forever while a battery doesn't. Batteries have gotten a lot better, but I think you need to look at the whole car, not just the motor, to make a fair assessment of durability. I do think that electric has a lower maintenance cost, even accounting for the battery, but it's not that low that i think you can make up a 30k price difference. If you plan on keeping the car for 10 years and drive 1000km per month. The up front 30k are 3k per year or 250 per month. That's quite a lot of an additional fixed cost for not having moved yet.
- misiti3780 6y agoyou can replace a tesla battery pack for 12K (after the warranty expires at 120K miles or 8 years), which i would imagine is probably be close to/less than the maintenance costs of a ICE vehicle after 120K miles/8 years
- carlmr 6y agoBut if it's similar to the maintenance cost, you've not gained anything on the initial cost differential. Making it still the worse investment.
- erik_seaberg 6y agoYou can get a four year old ICE car with 40K miles for ~$12K, so that’s probably too much to spend on maintaining a much older car (unless you’re sentimental about it).
- schmorptron 6y agoDo you think they'll still be making the batteries for an 8 year old car then? Ideally you'd be able to swap a newer battery that is better in some way in then, and maybe even have it a little cheaper than it is today if battery tech continues to get better, gonna be interesting to see how that plays out.
- NDizzle 6y agoI was looking at Volts two weeks ago. You can get a 2018 year model (premier trim level w/ driver confidence 2 - the highest possible trim level combination) with 13,000 miles on it for $17k. Due to living on dirt roads I passed on it, but it's a pretty good deal if you commute and can charge at your destination. 52 mile range all electric, 400 miles combined range.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI live rural Canada and drive plenty of dirt roads and have a Volt and ... no problems ever. It's got fairly low clearance, but it's heavy and has excellent traction. Handles excellent in snow with good winter tires.
- NDizzle 6y agoThe front splitter wouldn’t make it up my drive, much less the road. Cybertruck instead!
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThe bodywork will self-clearance if you let it.
- cwhiz 6y agoThe Volt is boring, ugly, and slow. I don’t know what they were thinking. It looks like it was designed by soccer moms in a focus group session.
- throwawayboise 6y agoYep. I think a big reason why Teslas are so popular and other EVs (and to a lesser extent Hybrids like the Prius) are not is the styling. Teslas look like normal cars. The others look like caricatures. It's subjective, but the styling of Volt, Bolt, Leaf, Prius, i3, id.3 are all turn-offs for me.
- Tagbert 6y agoThe Tesla M3 is rather homely and ill proportioned, though
- cptskippy 6y agoIt's a compliance car, they only wanted to sell as many as they needed to. This is pretty standard procedure. The car is passable but unappealing in most regards beyond the power train so that it appeals to only a very small segment of the population.
- wmeredith 6y agoI'm assuming you haven't driven one. They are not slow. My wife uses one asa. commuter car and it's fantastic. We just went through a long research phase of hybrids and surprisingly ended up with a Volt. (Chevy isn't really on my radar otherwise.)
- cwhiz 6y agoCome on, man. It is literally slower than a Honda Odyssey.
- djrogers 6y agoYou can’t gauge cost per mile without taking resale value into account, and tesla resale value is great, while the Volt? Not so much.... I’d bet if you owned each vehicle for 3-4 years then sold and actually did the math, the tesla would be ahead.
- supertrope 6y agoI find it unlikely that the depreciation on a $40K automobile is less than on a $30K one. If one is selling a car after only three years they should have leased it.
- Shivetya 6y agoMy 2017 Volt is what took me to my 2018 Model 3. Now I can no longer see myself driving any car that is not electric. This from someone who loves the sound of a good muscle car even to this day. GM's issue has always been they have played the compliance game while claiming otherwise. Even Ford is doing it now with the Mach E by limiting availability to 50k models, a number a third of the sales of vehicles they have cancelled for low unsustainable sales. I never bought my TM3 to save money, buying any new car pretty much is a losing proposition. I bought it because it was cool. It was the closest I have even seen to those dream/concept cars from the seventies and eighties. All those cars with radical exteriors and even more radical interiors. Well someone built it. Is it perfect. No. However as an EV is had my most important feature. Range. I could care less about its 0-60mph times. I want range. I want to drive to my friends in the boonies and back in all seasons without having to divert to charge. I want to be able to skip chargers because I have the range to do so. Plus remember, every range number given should be hedged by multiplying it by 0.90 as no manufacturer suggests charging to 100% all the time. On a side note : Do not buy FSD. Tesla will not let you transfer it to another Tesla and even right now trade ins to Tesla are hit and miss as they have been giving ZERO dollars on trade for the feature. You don't need it for lane keep assist or traffic aware cruise control. I don't care if you believe Tesla can or cannot deliver it, the simple matter here is they don't honor you by giving you anything for it on trade; something that Elon claims to be looking into
- nickik 6y agoMach-E started as a compliance EV and the realised that their compliance car might not sell at all and they would have to lose like 10-15k on each one of them, and potentially sell them in fairly large numbers compared to compliance cars of the past. So they have a team inside Ford and they basically told them to go all out on the vehicle and they did a nice job. These guys however are still sort of separate from overall Ford and the car is basically designed to sell well and not lose them to much money. Ford has the issue that they simply don't have battery supply to scale their EV production. They are getting batteries from LG in Europe right now but all new capacity is basically already reserved for all the Europeans. They simply can't copy the Model Y and sell 300k a year, specially because to match the Y in specs, they needed to put more battery into it. I agree with your point on FSD. They said they would start to value it during trade in now, but even so, when you sell it privately, if the buyer doesn't want FSD its harder to sell, its limits the pool of people who want it.
- nickik 6y agoIf you really care about cost and that is your only measure, then of course a Model 3 isn't it. However, you can get insane deal on some EV, like the Bolt. They are not close to Tesla in terms of many things, but if you just need to everyday driving, its perfectly reasonable.