3 ms·
The most useful and effective tool I've come across to use in a debate is to get the two sides to outline the position and argument of their critics as clearly
by simonh 6y ago
The most useful and effective tool I've come across to use in a debate is to get the two sides to outline the position and argument of their critics as clearly as hey can, to the satisfaction of their critics, before engaging in the debate. That's not really practical in internet forum comment wars, but I think if you come to the table with this spirit in mind it can be very helpful.
Arming yourself with rhetorical weapons like this, especially if you rather view them as tools for thinking, will get you some way but I think rarely aid in reaching consensus or understanding where disagreement comes from.
- tpoacher 6y agoI recommend an (old) book by Thouless called "Straight and Crooked Thinking" if you can get your hands on a copy. It goes through a list of "dishonest" debate techniques (not necessarily relying on fallacies) and possible techniques to disarm them.