4 ms·
I think appeal to authority gets shaky when you appeal to an authority who's domain of expertise, or specific knowledge and experience might not extend to the i
by simonh 6y ago
I think appeal to authority gets shaky when you appeal to an authority who's domain of expertise, or specific knowledge and experience might not extend to the issue at hand. It's a matter of trusting the process of scientific inquiry, challenge and verification, not just the person.
So for example I defer to Roger Penrose on anything to do with mathematics, and will absolutely he has earned a voice on astrophysics#, but quantum consciousness microtubules? Nobody is an authority on that, so who knows?
# And to be clear part of his credibility there is in making it clear what he believes with a high degree of certainty and what is more speculative.
- syops 6y agoYes, that is why I agree with appeal to false authority being a fallacy. This is what I was referring to in my last paragraph.