6 ms·
>if Apple was wielding this to harm users that'd be one thing walled gardens harm users by definition because they reduce competition. Forcing an open API woul
by Barrin92 6y ago
>if Apple was wielding this to harm users that'd be one thing
walled gardens harm users by definition because they reduce competition. Forcing an open API would immediately create the opportunity for people to offer competing clients for any Apple (or Facebook etc) service, drive down costs, produce new ways to interact with the services of large companies and so on, it would immediately unlock the ability of countless of independent creators to produce new products.
In fact if you were to open up Facebook, Apple's apis and so on and turned them into open protocols you would not even necessarily need invasive privacy regulation, people could just build a privacy respecting Facebook client that lets people interact with the service in a way they want, getting an algorithm free news feed if they want, stripping out baggage they don't need. It would solve a large majority of the exact issues that we have with large tech companies.
Apple does hold a monopoly over all Apple users, which gives them market power the same way a monopolistic company in a larger market exercises power. It's actually straight up depressing for someone to say "well I benefit from the walled garden". It's no different than someone saying "I like the oligarch because he treats me nicely"
- spideymans 6y agoSure, but consumers should be free to make that decision themselves. The government shouldn't force it upon them. Apple has not deceived consumers with regards to their App Store practices. On the contrary, they've been quite boastful about it. There are (and were) plenty of open computing platforms, allowing consumers to experience their benefits and tradeoffs. If consumers prefer to use a more locked down platform, then so be it.
- Barrin92 6y agoMost people don't even know what a world would look like in which power was taken away from large companies and a genuine market of services would exists that gives power back to the users and developers rather than platform owners. The hold that Apple has on its billion users and that Facebook has on its 2 billion is too strong to be solved by some magical third party. None of the large firms which control our digital infrastructure provides an actual protocols. The government should absolutely force it on Facebook and Apple and Google the same way the American government forced it on railroad barons a hundred years ago, when they were forced to make their networks interoperable. Imagine if Volkswagen owned the streets and you could only drive your car on 30% of all roads. Sure you can go to Toyota, you just have to drive in circles. We'd laugh anyone out of the room who actually defended this. Yet this is literally how the internet is structured right now. We live in little fiefdoms where Android users can't talk to imessage users because feudal lords have decided to draw a line across the territory.
- spideymans 6y ago>Most people don't even know what a world would look like in which power was taken away from large companies and a genuine market of services would exists that gives power back to the users and developers rather than platform owners. Consumers knew exactly what more open computing was like prior to the App Store. There were no App Store for Windows or OS X back in 2005, and you could largely install whatever applications you like onto the smartphone operating systems of the day. Evidently, a pretty large chunk of users decided the preferred the more restricted operating system with the "curated" store.
- Mindwipe 6y ago> Sure, but consumers should be free to make that decision themselves. Why? The state makes a variety of judgements that corporations cannot leave things up to user choice because that's too dangerous to wider society. Apple can't sell an iPhone that occasionally electrocutes users and out it down to "user choice." We rightly ban that.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stale2002 6y ago> If consumers prefer to use a more locked down platform, then so be it. There is nothing wrong with a consumer being allowed to choose to keep their own phone locked down. Thats not the problem. The problem is when you go to a consumer and tell them that they aren't allowed to open up their own property, in an easy way. You can keep your phone locked down. Just give other people the choice to also open up their own phone, easily, if they choose to do so.
- Jtsummers 6y ago> Apple does hold a monopoly over all Apple users Starbucks holds a monopoly over all Starbucks customers. If I want to be a Starbucks customer I have to go to Starbucks. Goddamn them I want to get my overpriced Starbucks coffee from Dairy Queen! Speaking of Dairy Queen, why are they the only ones that get to sell a Blizzard??!? ***** Your statement is just as nonsensical to me.
- echelon 6y agoStarbucks is pretty generic. I'm not locked into Starbucks coffee. In fact, in the past week alone I've bought coffee at both Starbucks and Dunkin. The product lines are similar and buying one does not preclude buying the other. There's zero lock in. Once you start using your iPhone, you stop buying Android apps. You also don't use Google Wallet.
- IOT_Apprentice 6y agoStarbucks is a corporation, it is not generic. You can't buy Dunkin at Starbucks. It is your choice to shop at either. Just as it is your choice to use either an iPhone using iOS or a phone using Android/Google etc. Just as it is your choice to choose a car from a particular manufacturer.
- fossuser 6y agoA closer analogy is Walmart deciding what goes on its shelves and it being hard for users to buy from any other store besides Walmart once they choose a “Walmart” device which locks them into their choice a bit. I can see the argument, I just don’t think the power is being wielded for consumer harm - if it was that’d be different. If Apple was blocking some company from their store everyone wanted because they were competing with an Apple product that’d be an issue. As it is they’re making it easy for their users to not be spied on. In the analogy it’d be Walmart checking that what they stock on shelves doesn’t poison their customers. Are they wielding power? Sure - is that monopoly abuse? No.
- dawg- 6y agoThe big point here is that Apple users choose the walled garden for themselves. Many people buy apple products specifically because of it. Of course apple holds a “monopoly” over their own users, exactly the same as how Walmart and Target hold a “monopoly” over the space within their own stores. If you don’t like the business model of Walmart because of how they have ruined local businesses, you can go shop at the farmers market or local organic shops. But you wouldn’t file a lawsuit which would demand that Walmart host the local farmers market in their own parking lot.