5 ms·
> FB has a point here, but I'm still hoping Apple wins - I'd rather than tracking model not be viable. I think it's possible for two things to be true simultan
by walrus01 6y ago
> FB has a point here, but I'm still hoping Apple wins - I'd rather than tracking model not be viable.
I think it's possible for two things to be true simultaneously:
a) it's bad and wrong for apple to demand 30%, or whatever it is, as a cut of any payment made inside an app distributed through their app store
b) apple blocking tracking and advertising networks at the operating system level (API calls between the app running on a phone or tablet, and the underlying OS) is a net benefit for the consumer end user. obviously apple has a very different perspective on this since they are not facebook, or google, and not dependent upon advertising revenue.
- Forge36 6y agoWhat's up stop b) from being "goodbye api" and completely removing it? I'd assume at some point any App could be expected to make required updates for a variety of reasons. Like any other tool: what obligations does a manufacturer have to continue creating replacement parts?
- dylan604 6y agoIf it is truly a manufacturer making replacement parts, then they have to have enough stock to fulfill warranty requests for the life of the warranty. Otherwise, they have to replace the entire thing.
- vineyardmike 6y agoB would result in more law suits faster, this way apple can claim "its the customers decision". Right now, people complain about apple making decisions for them. And, fwiw, i know people who actually opt-in to tracking (no idea why...)
- pradn 6y agob) Apple blocking tracking is only a net benefit if you value privacy enough to overweigh the drop in customers for niche businesses well served by targeted ads.
- kergonath 6y agoApple is not blocking tracking, though. Apple is putting the decision in the hands of the user.
- pradn 6y agoThe practical effect is a massive decrease in tracking information for companies- defaults are powerful. I agree with Apple’s decision. It’s just going to have negative effects for some businesses, which is a price that must be considered against the gain in privacy.
- kergonath 6y agoIt will have effects, sure. But they still don’t prevent tracking, and if the trade off is so compelling for users as some people here seem to imply, then users will just accept it. It is difficult to say that the users being aware of what they are giving away is a bad thing, unless you are a crook whose business model is based on deception.
- sahila 6y agoThat's not you evaluate giving up a person's privacy. Otherwise your argument is akin to saying we should force X millionaire to give up all his money to y group of people because of the net benefit.
- mrzimmerman 6y agoWell in the case of the USA taxation is part of the constitution. Privacy is too but that relates to how the government surveils you and not necessarily how a private company collects info on you as you use their product. So I guess I’m saying your comparison is specious.