7 ms·
The second order effects are problematic though. Someone shorting a stock has an incentive to see a company fail. Sometimes people will put out rumors or even
by jandrese 6y ago
The second order effects are problematic though. Someone shorting a stock has an incentive to see a company fail. Sometimes people will put out rumors or even go on fiance shows talking about how poorly run some company is. Maybe they make a discreet call to their buddy at the ratings agency and have them downgraded a step. If the market's stated purpose is to help companies find the capital they need to succeed, then short sellers run counter to that purpose.
If however the purpose of the market is to be a big game for people with huge amounts of mostly virtual currency to gamble with then short selling is a vital instrument.
One problem with the market is that value is not based on what a company is worth, it is based on what investors think it might be worth in the future, which is largely just a guess. So the whole thing becomes divorced from reality while investors play games with each other to try to make the numbers go up as fast as possible.
- kansface 6y ago> Someone shorting a stock has an incentive to see a company fail. How is that incentive any different than the incentives of someone taking the opposite position: > Sometimes people will put out rumors or even go on fiance shows talking about how ~poorly~ well run some company is.
- valuearb 6y agoThe stock markets purpose isn’t to help companies find money, that Pr spin. It’s to help investors invest their monies more cheaply and safely. The side effect is that companies get cheaper access to investment funds. Without short sellers frauds would be even more prevalent, investor costs would be higher and companies would raise less money. If you have a solvent company brought down by a short seller, you never had a solvent company. And value != price. True investors like Buffett don’t really mind the casino aspect, because volatility creates opportunities when value diverges far from price.
- jcranmer 6y ago> Sometimes people will put out rumors or even go on fiance shows talking about how poorly run some company is. Maybe they make a discreet call to their buddy at the ratings agency and have them downgraded a step. Some people buy a stock, and then put out rumors or even go on finance shows talking about how great this company is and how its stock is undervalued. And then sell it at the peak, leaving others holding the bag. Yet people don't run around saying that we should ban people from being able to buy stock because of that. Both the scenarios (the one you describe and the one I describe) are illegal market manipulation. Sure, I would not be surprised if market manipulation of the short side were vastly underprosecuted, but I don't think that's a reason to complain about short selling per se.
- jrowen 6y agoYet people don't run around saying that we should ban people from being able to buy stock because of that. I honestly wonder if we should sometimes. I struggle to see how the real value created by this whole system outweighs the negatives. It’s been abstracted too far away from "investing in a company" and created too many perverse incentives. Too many people playing numbers games and gambling, under the impression that they're creating value somehow. HFT? How is that anything but absurd? I feel like we’d be better off going back to a more simple system where actual people have actual skin in the companies they're taking ownership of.
- tptacek 6y agoHFT (electronic market making in general, HFT being a particularly potent expression of it) drastically lowered transaction costs for retail investors, and most theories of how HFT is harmful or absurd are based on a lack of understanding of market structure. Is how it's something other than absurd.
- jrowen 6y agoOh, I wouldn’t even call my idle layman thoughts a theory, more of a hunch really. Have retail investors generally benefitted from doing an amount of trading that would incur significant transaction costs? Do you think my general sentiment is off base, and the market (as is) is unequivocally a good thing for society as a whole? Even with regular worldwide crises caused by wild speculation, greed, and incompetence? I would be very interested to read a thorough defense of how the increasingly complex market machinations and instruments are good for “the people” and some indication that their value isn’t entirely captured by the small cohort that dreamed them up. I admit that I understand this very poorly.
- tptacek 6y agoA thing retail investors have always done (placing orders to buy and sell stocks) used to cost a lot. Now it's practically free. You can flee to a more abstract argument about whether investing itself is bad, but I'm not interested in debating that, only in observing that HFT had a large hand in eliminating those costs. I note further that you only attempted to rebut one of the two points I made in my comment.
- quickthrowman 6y ago> The second order effects are problematic though. Someone shorting a stock has an incentive to see a company fail. Sometimes people will put out rumors or even go on fiance shows talking about how poorly run some company is. “ Tesla CEO Elon Musk had a number of things to talk about during Wednesday's quarterly earnings call, but spent a lot of time discussing the company's Full Self-Driving system. According to Musk, the FSD will be capable of Level 5 autonomy by the end of 2021.” How is Elon Musk claiming (lying) that level 5 FSD will be available for Tesla vehicles in 2021 any different from short sellers making similar claims about the potential downsides of a stock? FWIW, Elon Mysk said they’ll have a million robotaxis operating before the end of 2020. I believe there are 0 currently operating. [1] I will bet anyone 10,000 dollars that Tesla will not have level 5 FSD by EOY. If anyone is willing to lend me money to make the bet, I’ll bet as much as they’ll lend me. [0] https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/elon-musk-full-self-driving-tesla-earnings-call/ https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/elon-musk-full-self-drivi... [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/22/elon-musk-says-tesla-robotaxis-will-hit-the-market-next-year.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/22/elon-musk-says-tesla-robotax...
- mianos 6y agoBecause he works there. He has the most information possible. He is not guessing. The SEC is quite clear about how this has to be honest disclosure. He has been rebuked several times for this. It is not unreasonable for companies to miss targets and when the forward looking information they provide at investor briefings may be less trusted and this would normally be reflected in the stock price change. Experienced investors make long term investment decisions with this sort of thing in mind. Not everything goes to plan but if this was fabricated it would be illegal and is very commonly pursued by the authorities.