3 ms·
>> Always talk to the police -- AFTER GETTING IMMUNITY. No no no, a thousand times no. Immunity is a very nuanced thing that, in the US especially, is beyond
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> Always talk to the police -- AFTER GETTING IMMUNITY.
No no no, a thousand times no. Immunity is a very nuanced thing that, in the US especially, is beyond the understanding of laypersons. Talk only to and through YOUR lawyer. Don't go anywhere near any talk of "immunity" without several days to discuss the matter with paid legal counsel.
- cogman10 6y agoAnd, AFAIK, the police themselves CANNOT GRANT IMMUNITY. Only the prosecutor can sign an immunity deal with you. By the time you are talking to a prosecutor, you should have your lawyer involved.
- sandworm101 6y agoNot even the prosecutor. The US is a strange dual sovereignty system (state and federal) and so you need multiple prosecutors to agree. State immunity can be respected by the feds, and vis versa, but that is not absolute. Similarly, US prosecutors cannot grant immunity for crimes in other countries such as crimes that cross boarders. US immunity might mean end many travel options.
- senkora 6y agoI’m not sure I would call that “strange”; it’s just the meaning of federalism. Federal means that subnational units have some limited sovereignty, versus unitary where only the toplevel government has sovereignty.
- sandworm101 6y agoNot really. Canada is federalized, but still has a unitary authority for prosecution of crimes. There are very few countries operating parallel authorities, parallel criminal courts. Most countries have a unitary authority structure with the national government being the highest source of law. The US operates a bifurcated structure where States (50+ of them) are often the final authority on criminal matters. That is strange.
- senkora 6y agoOkay, fair. I meant that dual sovereignty itself isn’t strange, but I see that you meant specifically wrt criminal courts. I’ll defer to you on that since I don’t know much about it.