3 ms·
I just started to read it, not finished yet, so I will update this post a needed. Also, I look at it from a purely supply chain / logistics erspective. I also a
by hef19898 6y ago
I just started to read it, not finished yet, so I will update this post a needed. Also, I look at it from a purely supply chain / logistics erspective. I also asusme that the other contracts (Biontech/Pfizer, Moderna, Jihnsson&Johnsson,...) are similar.
So far, I found this:
- Paragraph 5.2: The delivery schedule in the main contract is quite short ( I assume based on quarters) and blacked out. I don't like that lack of transparence.
- Paragraph 6.2: I read that paragraph concerning capacit limitations, that of any additional EU orders result in capacity shortfalls, AZ has to increase capacity. And in case AZ is not able to adhere to the schedule agreed in 5.2, AZ is not in breach of contract. If the Pfizer contract is the same, that would mean the EU really shot itself in the foot with the additional orders, that forced a temporary / partial shitdown of Pfizers Belgian plant.
- 6.3: Regular reporting intevalls are not specified, neither is any appendix referenced. That could be an issue.
- 8.1, Delivery: Coordination of deliveries is supposed to happen between the central AZ rep and the reps o the EU member states. Again no details, no mention of working groups, no detailed time tables, eg AZ has to inform "in good time" before doses will be available. I'd say very hard o implement once deliveries are supposed to start, and a clear indication that nobody thought of how the whole purchasing and delivery to member state hubs is supposed to work in real life.
- 8.4 and 8.5: Now the contract specifies "in good time" to be 5 working days. Distribution is up to member states. And in case the hub cannot take the delivery within these 5 days, any storage is on the member state. The period behind this is blacked out. The focus here is purely cost, again I'd say the cintract is falling short on the logistcs side of things.
- 18.7, Force Majeur: Sure, pandemics are usually included as Force Majeur incidents. But really, for a COVID-19 vaccine as well? Come on. The means either the pandemic is delcared over (which it won't be), or AZ has a constant option to just declare Force Majeur if they run into issues. Why not explicitly exclude the ongoing pandemic from being a Force Majeur event?
- Order Form (pages 35 through 38): This is honestly the first contract I saw in my whole life, that spends fou complete pages on cntractually specifying the purchase order. Honestly, I don't see reason why.
- Delivery Schedule (page 40): Now we have a table with monthly quantities. All blacked out. Again, the contract references payment terms, but not a single word on what happens if AZ canno adhere to the schedule. Not good.
I have to say, from a supply chain perspective, this contract is dangerously lacking. Based on my experience with government sourcing, they tend to include everything in the cntract they think about, I assume nobody spared a thought at how the deliveries wil bemanaged,how the schedule will look like, or what will happen if there are delays. That almost borders negligence.
Again, asuming the contracts with the other suppliers are similar, I'm almost sure that there is no organization put in place on EU level, at the suppliers or member states to manage the actual deliveries. None. There is no word in that contract about thecoordination between local vaccination efforts and deliveries. I have the impression, that as with masks, the governments think that you sign a contract, place an order and then have the goods are delivered without issues. It didn't work out like that with masks, it won't with vaccines.
- Closi 6y agoI’m in logistics too, although deliveries seemed pretty flexible from my perspective. 5 days is a huge window (retailers will fine you if you arrive outside their 2 hour window!). Delivery into any specified single NDC seems sensible. More specifics around delivery requirements and regulations will differ on a by-country basis regardless.
- hef19898 6y agoYou are right. The main difference I see, so, is that in the case of the retailer delivery windows are defined by the retailer. In the case of vaccines, I have the impression, that AZ informs customers when a batch is ready. And then the customers have to accept delivery within 5 days. That means AZ is driving the whole supply chain to certain extent, and not the states being responsible for the vaccinations. A single DC is sensible, Germany has a total of 16 for the Pfizer vaccine. As states have a lot of independence in Germany, I fear that every state has its own DC for AZ as well. How that middle mile will be organised, I have no idea.
- Closi 6y agoYeah, supermarkets generally operate on a pull from suppliers, while the nature of this is definitely a push from AZ, although I can’t see it working any other way effectively. Middle mile will be organised via transhipment / trunking. Transshipment from an NDC via a regional hub is a very common practice and I would be surprised if anyone has a network with 16 regional hubs without an NDC to support them.
- hef19898 6y agoIn theory you are right. Using national DCs to switch from push to oull would just work smoothly. I can only talk about Germany so, but I was in conctact with authorities last year regarding mask distribution. and what I saw back then was shocking. They had one logistics partner for import and central warehousing. i know that company, and they should have been able to organise ditribution as well, evne if for that part there would have been better companies. And everything up to the central warehouse worked justfine. Everything after that was a mess, they had million sof masks sittin in the warehouse while doctors, hospitals and everyone else had to make due with what they got themselves until their normal suppliers managed to supply them again. At which point nobody wanted (due to price) or needed the government sourced masks anymore. The answer I got from the bavarian Ministry of Interior, the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Economics was, I paraphrase, "distribution is easy, we can handle that". 3 months later the same people said they underestimated distribution. Ideally, I would say that vaccination centers should never run out of doses. So there should be more doses in these centers than appointments. Appointments is a mess, even for elderly and risk patients. One could also piggy back on the existing vaccine supply chains, using doctors practices. I am not aware of any plans to do so. In case appointment management would work, one could allign these appointments with push deliveries from AZ and others. Manufacturers would have a forecast, push deliveries based on forecast would end up in the national hubs and supply of local centers would work using something like Knban loops. Easy, robust and scalable. Not that we will see any of this, or other solutions that would actually work, antime soon in Germany. So I expect it go down something like this: 1. manufacturer informs that a batch is available. 2. Bacth is delivered to central hub, in quite some cases tha hub cannot take the delivery resulting in a mess to get the doses at a later point 3. Once the doses are in the hub, authorities will (try) to reach out to eligible people that they can get vaccinations 4. two weeks after the batch is delivered, the first appointments will be available 5. Vaccination centers will not be able to vaccinate everyone with an appointment beause the supply with doses isn't working 6. Three weeks after the batch was delivered, it will partially be used 7. Repeat with the next batch Joker: Political blame game and glory hunting, we have quite a lot of elections, including the federal one, this year. To be inserted at any point of the above chain, likely multiple times.