3 ms·
> Free speech has nothing to do with it. Nothing. Absolutely nothing. That doesn't make sense. Any restrictions on speech (e.g. prohibiting lying in commercial
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
> Free speech has nothing to do with it. Nothing. Absolutely nothing.
That doesn't make sense. Any restrictions on speech (e.g. prohibiting lying in commercials, prohibiting yelling fire in a crowded room, etc.) always need to go through the lens of whether there is a "legitimate government interest", because the courts have been very clear that any restrictions on speech much have a clear rationale. If the SEC wants to argue that posts on a public website forum are somehow collusion, they need to argue why those posts are not protected by the first amendment.
Of course, it's easy to come up with a clear rationale for why one would limit speech in this case, and "commercial" speech is much more open to restrictions. However, I don't see how one could argue "I'm buying a shit ton of GME, and I think you should too, because I want to screw over the hedge fund guys" is any different, just because it's on a forum, from all the other types of investment advice and theories that goes out all the time.