3 ms·
> Why is everyone getting mad at Robinhood? They were the first to suddenly block buying (but not selling!) GME when everyone in retail wanted to buy, and they
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
> Why is everyone getting mad at Robinhood?
They were the first to suddenly block buying (but not selling!) GME when everyone in retail wanted to buy, and they refuse to explain why.
> Wasn't it the market makers who stopped them from trading GME?
Who knows? They refuse to explain anything.
> And doesn't Robinhood have the right to sell margin stocks bought on margin?
Yes. That part of the anger is misplaced. But it's not a significant part of the drama anyway.
- tptacek 6y agoThey haven't refused to explain why. Very Online People just don't accept their explanation.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWell, they've published a blog post. And got CEO on the news. But what they offered was not an explanation. The explanation they offered in their blog post: "As a brokerage firm, we have many financial requirements, including SEC net capital obligations and clearinghouse deposits. Some of these requirements fluctuate based on volatility in the markets and can be substantial in the current environment. These requirements exist to protect investors and the markets and we take our responsibilities to comply with them seriously, including through the measures we have taken today." That's not an explanation, that's just hot air. What financial requirements? What capital obligations and clearinghouse deposits? Which requirements fluctuate based on volatility? How do these requirements protect the investors and the markets? And ultimately, how exactly any of this leads to them blocking buy orders on $GME?
- tptacek 6y agoWe have so many sources, from multiple brokerages, about increased capital requirements to clear GME and AMC trades that it has revived discussions about whether there are bad unintended consequences of the Dodd-Frank regulations that centralized clearing, which have the impact of transmuting private company risk management policies (that protect systemically important firms like DTCC) into global financial policy. But you've managed to dismiss all this as "hot air", thus, I would suggest, confirming my suggestion that Very Online People simply don't accept the fairly clear explanation of what happened. It seems reasonable to fault Robinhood for shitty comms (though, as 'JumpCrisscross pointed out yesterday, the general rule is "aviate, navigate, then communicate"), but the endemic message board pathology is to use shitty comms to justify conspiracy theories, which are more fun to talk about than reality and take over these threads like algae.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoEverybody here correctly divined what you mention, and then could confirm it after other trading apps went on to actually shed some light towards what's going on. My point is exactly the shitty comms of Robin Hood - they were the first to make this move, they gave no reasonable explanation. It doesn't matter what we know now. What matters is that RH's users didn't know then.
- tptacek 6y agoIn light of this comment I can't really understand what you meant by the last paragraph of your last comment. Were you actually asking? Or did you know, and know that RH's answers to those questions were in fact not nefarious, and just want to keep the drama alive a bit longer?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI get the high-level picture, I'm somewhat unclear about the details, and I'm not sure iff this even applies to Robin Hood, because they didn't confirm any of this. That's all irrelevant, though. The top-level question here was, why people are angry at Robin Hood. My explanation is simple: they cut a lot of people off buying at the moment they wanted to buy, and provided no explanation. Any theory as to why they did that comes from taking explanations of other traders and the mechanics, not from anything RH said. If you think what they published was sufficient explanation (and remember, the target audience is mostly regular folks with even less clue about stock market than I have), then why did RH's CEO get drilled by the news on the same questions I'm listing? Apparently the newscasters and their audiences also don't believe he answered anything.
- tptacek 6y agoFirst, it's Robinhood, not Robin Hood. Second: I'm not interested in the binary of whether or not people are mad at Robinhood. People should be mad at Robinhood for a variety of reasons, most notably that it is an online casino masquerading as an investment app. I am very interested in the conspiracy theory that says Robinhood halted GME orders as part of an effort to protect hedge funds. That conspiracy was repeated by a number of legislators yesterday, seemingly encouraging ordinary people to follow on this terribly risky GME bubble. The conspiracy appears to be false. If we don't disagree, we don't disagree.
- cardiffspaceman 6y agoNaturally, many longs were in on margin. RH asserted their right under their TOS to margin call without notice. This might be legal, but it looks like mining the retail investors for gold. I think it should NEVER happen. A firm like RH should instead gather its fortitude and fund itself to ride such events out, and ALWAYS give accounts five days to respond to a margin call. To do otherwise is to "undermine market confidence" in the words of the SEC.
- jedmeyers 6y ago> And doesn't Robinhood have the right to sell margin stocks bought on margin? Only if they issue a margin call. But what if they were the ones responsible for the conditions that lead to the margin call in the first place (blocking buys on a specific stock)?