10 ms·
Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect technique [video]
- ogre_codes 6y agoI want one that shocks you whenever I push a button.
- terse_malvolio 6y agoExcept when you look at videos of the world record level typists, they don't always type with 'proper' technique.
- kemitchell 6y agoI noticed fairly recently that I often, but not always, type the letter "P" with my ring finger, rather than my little (pinky) finger. I'm still not sure whether that's adaptive or wrong. Have you seen good resources on high-speed typing technique?
- MaxLeiter 6y agoGet an ergonomic (probably split) keyboard and use your thumb for modifier keys. It’s meant to rotate all around unlike our pinkies.
- thom 6y agoI’ve been using a couple of split keyboards over the last year and it’s slowed me down because I can no longer cross over the keyboard to type a letter with either hand. This means you sometimes have to use the same finger twice in a row which always feels inefficient to me.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- colanderman 6y agoI don't think I use the pinky for any letter, only Enter and modifiers. Pinkies are weak. If you allow your forearm to move, rather than keeping your fingers in a "home" position, you do not need to use pinkies to reach letters.
- fireattack 6y agoI'm similar but worse, I basically type all the upper row with ring and middle finger only.
- desmap 6y agoIt's wrong but the p is on a very hard position for the right pinky. FWIW, p was the last letter I got right as a touch typist. It's not that the pinky is a weak finger--it can be trained to a very good level--it's really more the position of the p.
- thom 6y agoI’ve just moved p down a row on most of my keyboards.
- Arainach 6y agoSprinting and marathon running have very different technique. Life (and a career involving computers) is a marathon, and that's what ergonomics is about.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kkoncevicius 6y agoThe idea that the "proper" touch typing technique is ergonomic is not unquestionable. I've read some forums about RSI and there were quite a few people stating they got RSI right at the time they started learning and using the proper touch-typing method. It makes sense too. Without formal training your hands will assume comfortable positions on the keyboard and the writing technique will evolve to suit your hand size and your movements. This should be more ergonomic compared to strict rules, developed for type-writers, where you have to press each key with the same finger every time, and where typical programming keys (brackets, colons) are left to the smallest finger.
- Arainach 6y agoWhat is comfortable initially is not guaranteed (or even likely) to be repeatable thousands of times. Look at weight lifting - if you ask an untrained person to lift a barbell or heavy bag the way that "feels natural", they'll probably lift with their back or do something else that would cause major problems if done repeatedly over the long term.
- colanderman 6y agoI am a self-taught typist from a young age. I type very fast (140 WPM? I forget) but my technique is totally non standard. I hold my hands/wrists at "natural" angles (as one would on a split keyboard), but on a standard keyboard. No "home row" for me. The letters in the middle of the keyboard are liable to be typed by either hand, depending on the word: I cannot use a split keyboard because of this. Thumb helps out with lower row sometimes. I can type single-handedly without much difficulty. I credit this "technique" with not having developed any sort of keyboard-related RSI over 30 years of daily typing. Mice gave me terrible grip-related RSI after a decade (I now use a trackball), but not so with typing. I assume I'm not unique in having stumbled naturally on this method. But it's not something I've ever seen taught, probably because it's not very "orderly".
- klyrs 6y agoInteresting. I hold my left hand roughly on the home row, but like you, my right hand is at an odd angle. As a programmer, this seems very natural to me because I have rapid access to the brackets, parens, etc. without stretching my pinky. Coincidentally, I use a trackball too.
- userbinator 6y agoI'm pretty much the same as you --- the best description of my method would be "closest available finger". I can type at ~150WPM for long periods of time without any strain or tiredness, can reach 200+ in short bursts, and have done over 50WPM with only the left hand. However, one thing I've found that really affects typing speed and comfort is the key travel and actuation force; I think a "light, spongy, bouncy" feel is best. A light force reduces strain, sponginess is a good cushion, and the bounce helps speed up the return stroke. You can type a lot faster once you train yourself to not try to await any tactile feedback, but just "trust" that you've hit the keys and they've actuated.
- dataflow 6y agoHow in the world do you type 50WPM with just the left hand? Do you practice the right hand side of the keyboard with your left hand?
- logbiscuitswave 6y agoRight? I don’t really use all my fingers most of the time. It’s pretty unorthodox. I can easily get 120+ WPM with pretty good correctness. I’m self taught so I just picked up something that worked for me at a young age and ran with it. I can be insecure about it sometimes but since it works well enough for me I haven’t had much motivation to “fix” it.
- mhh__ 6y ago"All 14 checks failed" => Old Sparky
- klodolph 6y agoThis is something that would also be lovely for those people trying to learn musical instruments. Without this component, programs like Rocksmith are a lot less valuable than they could be.
- 0x4a42 6y agoI see the potetnial for a VIM 101 course. :)
- akdor1154 6y agoCool idea, obnoxious video though. I hate things that are geared at an audience with a five second attention span.
- netsharc 6y agoWelcome to 2021, I'm wondering if he was 1 of the 2 kids shown in the beginning of the video, but yeah kid's probably 17 years old and playing with neural networks... Nothing wrong with that, I'm just old and bitter.
- throw14082020 6y agoYou undoubtedly make mistakes in the learning process, so this is actually a bad idea for learning. This would scare you into looking at the keyboard, thus preventing you from actually learning. I type at ~100WPM (which is higher than average but im sure some of you are faster ;) ). I've learn new keyboard layouts (split, colemak), and the best way to learn is to not look at keyboard, and try to remember where the keys are (and constantly trying to type as fast possible [using muscle memory instead of memory], which makes even more mistakes).
- dstick 6y agoI’ve heard this advice before but I find it really demotivating. I recently realized that I type with all 5 fingers on my left hand but hit 90% of the keys with my index finger on the right. I’m fast mind you - 90-100wpm blind as well. But for any prolonged stretches (10 minute+) it starts to hurt. So a while back I started doing 10 minute a day typing exercises with Typing Academy to train my right hand. Whenever I did it blind it was just mistake after mistake after mistake. I felt so incapable. But when I started looking down I was able to correct myself and still use the right technique. Much better. I was slow. But slowly learning without frustration. I guess my point is: crawl before you walk, walk before you run. The frustration made me quit, and that’s always worse than looking down and learning.
- alpaca128 6y agoFor me the issue solved itself when I started using my first columnar staggered ergo keyboard, meaning instead of having the key rows slightly misaligned for historical reasons it has a different height for each column of keys to accomodate the different finger lengths. Doesn't sound like such a drastic change, but within minutes it will teach the user in what ways they've been typing incorrectly all along - and in what ways the standard keyboard layouts actually promote incorrect typing. It takes some time to get up to speed again, but nowadays I type using all fingers evenly ~95% of the time, simply because in contrast to the off-the-shelf design it makes correct typing far more comfortable while requiring quite some finger gymnastics to pull it off any other way. Of course due to the different design it's not quite as flexible, for example it's not great for gaming and mainly shines when the mouse is used sparingly. But as I mainly work with text it's been a great experience for me.
- Lemmih 6y agoI have a bad habit of pressing shift with the same hand I use to hit a character. Eg. I'd hit Shift_L + T (both left hand) instead of Shift_R + T (hand hand for T, right hand for Shift_R). I wish that was an easy way to configure my shift keys to only modify keys on the opposite side of the keyboard. It's kinda possible through xmodmap but it's a PITA to set up.
- desmap 6y agoUse Autohotkey, it's not really a big thing, e.g. <+t::return
- function_seven 6y agoI use a QMK keyboard, and wrote some code for the firmware that would enforce this in the keyboard itself. "Naughty" combinations like you listed would just NO_OP instead of emitting a scan code. It was frustrating as hell. Which, I guess is the point at first. But I got tired of it faster than I learned to balance the key presses. I wonder if just a small beep or other subtle signal would work? Allow the wrong combo, but give the typist some feedback.
- Ambroisie 6y agoDo you have a hosted version of that source code somewhere? I have been thinking about doing this with my own keyboard at some point.
- function_seven 6y agoOkay this is wild. I went looking to see if I could find the file, and came up empty. I don’t know what I did with it. Then I started wondering if I really did do this or if I had done it in autohotkey instead. So then I searched to see if somebody else had created one, and found this[1] I wrote that! So there’s my file. I don’t know if I made any improvements to it since posting that, since I can’t find it anymore. Let me know if you encounter any bugs. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/olkb/comments/8mxpdp/qmk_code_to_enforce_correct_shift_key_usage/ https://www.reddit.com/r/olkb/comments/8mxpdp/qmk_code_to_en...
- janwillemb 6y agoReminds me of the "share the pain" program by Microsoft: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9ttBt-4vWo https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9ttBt-4vWo
- jzer0cool 6y agoWhen programming y'all able to access all the bracket set <>()[]{} and special symbols !@#$....?/,., well without looking at the keyboard? I never gained proficiency to do that. And these days, I feel I use the backspace/delete key too often.
- wodenokoto 6y agoDo you use US layout? I’d say most of those very difficult on non-us (especially Mac!) and after I switched from Nordic keyboard to US I had a small epiphany about why we use the symbols we use in programming. But honestly it doesn’t matter. I glance at the key it while typing. There is nothing wrong with that
- luizfelberti 6y agoI'd second this. Switching to US ANSI layout (not US International layout) is like magic, I find it so much better that I always import my keyboards from the US, and only buy laptops if they have the US layout. Brazil uses a national standard called ABNT2 (which I consider to be an awful format), but to my advantage, I find the way Macs do accentuation (at least for latin alphabets) to be quite sensible (alt+vowel), and get angry whenever I have to use Linux because it doesn't have "Mac accents" For your case though, I think the Nordic alphabet might be trickier on the US layout, since it shares less common ground and there's a lot more to it
- mr_t 6y agoNever used it so far, but recently came across the NEO keyboard layout [1]. Unfortunately the website is in German only, but just looking at the interactive graphic should give you sufficient information how it looks like. The only German word you need to know to understand the graphic is „Ebene“, which means layer. What I find particularly interesting is „Ebene 3“, or „layer 3“ and the corresponding repurposing of the capslock key. Personally I definitely intend to try the NEO layout soon. [1] https://neo-layout.org/ https://neo-layout.org/
- StavrosK 6y agoI don't have 100% accuracy with the symbols in the numbers (except the parentheses), but am pretty good with them. Nowadays I've remapped the parentheses to left/right shift and the brackets to Tab+hjkl, so it's much easier.
- walrus01 6y agoSomewhat reminds me of the Linux setup that will rm -rf your whole hard drive upon the first incorrectly formatted shell command. Now combine that with the electroshock keyboard... https://qntm.org/suicide https://qntm.org/suicide
- __jf__ 6y agoI’ve been using a “First Principles (tm)” branded keyboard for years. It has 3 USB plugs to satisfy its power req’s and delivers shocks when found out visiting Stackoverflow.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThis could be a platform. ‘Keyboard that shocks... . if you argue with someone on the internet’ . if you are on facebook for more than 10 minutes’ . if you are about to send bank details to a scammer’ . if you are about to short GME’
- m463 6y ago- if you try to back out of the shopping cart. - if you dismiss the warranty upsell too quickly (have you noticed amazon has quietly BECOME best buy?) - if you try to cancel your service - continuously while reading the privacy policy.
- keehun 6y agoAs a trumpet player, I've heard of a story where a young student kept having this one issue with a technique in how the right hand is used to push down on the valves and rigged his trumpet such that there would be pain involved if he kept doing that. His bad right-hand technique was fixed within the week, I heard. In a less extreme version of this, trumpet teachers often have their students put a penny between the valve button and the fingertip because too many students unnecessarily lift up their fingers which causes the slightest of delays and unnecessary motion when depressing the valve next time.
- frabert 6y agoCurious, I "suffer" from a similar problem regarding guitar playing: I tend to lift all the fingers I'm not currently using away from the fretboard as I play, which would make most guitar teachers recoil in horror I imagine. I never got away from this habit, but I can still manage to reach "decent" speeds, despite of this problem. No possibility of putting dimes between fingers and strings in my case, unfortunately!
- thom 6y agoI was trained to touch type by being addicted to IRC in the 90s. So if I want to type all lowercase with no symbols I’m like 150WPM but unfortunately slower with code.
- touisteur 6y agoMissed opportunity for Typing of the Dead accessory!
- shultays 6y agoThere is also "deldo": https://youtu.be/D1sXuHnf_lo https://youtu.be/D1sXuHnf_lo (Slight nsfw)