3 ms·
> In no other occupation, that I can think of, can so many rules and directives be flouted without losing ones job, as is the case with modern police. That isn
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> In no other occupation, that I can think of, can so many rules and directives be flouted without losing ones job, as is the case with modern police.
That isn't really true. Have you read half the corporate policies published by large companies? Neither have most of their employees. Nobody cares and they're not enforced until Something Bad happens, at which point it's time to open the book for the first time to see which rule the designated scapegoat can be found to have broken.
The problem with the police is that the institutional Something Bad doesn't align with the actually bad things that happen when they break the rules. The institutional Something Bad is bad press.
The actual bad thing is sending an innocent person to prison while a guilty one stays free to continue committing robberies and murders. Or the same sort of "bring me the man, I'll find you the crime" except used by the police against dissidents and anti-authoritarians instead of the people presiding over some corporate incompetence.
But when that doesn't result in bad press, nobody gets punished and then it keeps happening.
This is why it's important to have a media willing to hold any administration's feet to the fire. Ironically, getting the election results many of the people who care about this wanted is having the opposite effect, as now the pressure is off to actually do anything about the problem.
Complaining about it when the other guy is in is rhetorically advantageous; actually doing something about it when you're in costs political capital. So now we get to see what they do. But based on the existing media rhetoric, the implication seems to be more police state rather than less.
Of course, the media is not just The Media, it's also this. So write your Congress critters.
- kwhitefoot 6y ago> Nobody cares and they're not enforced until Something Bad happens, That's not my experience. I'm not claiming that it is never true just that as far as I can tell, in the UK and Norway, it is mostly not.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoI would certainly believe that this is different outside of the US. The US is very litigious and as a result the rule book is often long and complicated enough that nobody really understands it because it's written by lawyers to avoid liability rather than as a set of practical measures designed to improve real outcomes. Also, whenever Something Bad happens they generally add new rules to address it, even if the existing rules would have prevented it had people been following them. So the complexity grows over time and makes it less likely that anybody even reads the rules, much less implements them. This also differs by industry or even by which rule book it is. If you have reasonable policies for handling hazardous materials, people follow them because if they don't then they get hurt. But even in the same company, the company policy on other things only gets followed if it gets enforced, and only gets enforced if not doing so caused trouble in practice.
- handoflixue 6y agoI think there's two key differences here: 1) The police can get away with stuff even when the public has clear video proof of wrong-doing. Usually that's enough to at least trigger the "sacrifice a scapegoat" process, but not here. 2) The police can get away with violating not only policy, but actual laws.
- danShumway 6y agoRight. I'm less sympathetic to this argument than I was years ago when I first started paying more attention to police corruption, because since then I've watched widespread protests happen over police brutality, and I've watched prosecutors literally just refuse to charge the officers involved. The protests didn't matter, prosecutors would not consciously attack the people on "their side." It's an argument that sounds good, and in a system that wasn't so fundamentally broken, it might even be true. But it doesn't hold up to the reality we're seeing with police departments. We're past the point where we can describe the problem as just being about education or awareness. The current system is brazen.