3 ms·
> As far as I can tell, HN mods focus more on how you say something rather than what you say. If you're civil, respectful, and on-topic you're seemingly allowed
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> As far as I can tell, HN mods focus more on how you say something rather than what you say. If you're civil, respectful, and on-topic you're seemingly allowed to present just about any idea.
Absolutely, and it’s an excellent principle! Notably, however, HN does restrict what types of stories can be submitted, which has much the same effect of limiting what "ideas can be presented" (particularly when combined with an expectation to stay on topic).
To me, the difference is that HN isn’t trying to be a one-stop destination for all of your communication, whereas Facebook absolutely is.
Which is to say, I agree that complete free speech on any individual website is impossible without it devolving into a hellscape, so the best way to support free speech on a societal level is to have a diversity of social networks, instead of a handful of major platforms.
And we're failing at the diversity part.
- tjchear 6y agoWouldn't a diversity of social media platforms each restricted to a niche produce echo chambers? Not making a case for Facebook, I just don't think we have a good solution to this yet.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoIt's a valid concern, but ultimately, a diversity of online spaces more closely matches the real world. The types of conversations which are acceptable at your workplace, your gym, your favorite bar, and your political party's local action committee will all be different, but there's enough cross-pollination that democracy seems to have always worked. From where I'm standing, the rise of Facebook et al's recommendation algorithms seems to have been far more effective at creating echo chambers. And importantly, these algorithms only really work if they have a wealth of potential content to recommend—ie, if the social network is absolutely massive!