3 ms·
The mean quality of amateur designs is lower, but the variance is much, much higher. When a creative market reaches a scale where thousands or hundreds of thou
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
The mean quality of amateur designs is lower, but the variance is much, much higher.
When a creative market reaches a scale where thousands or hundreds of thousands of amateurs can experiment with new designs, the number of outliers surpassing the quality of professional designs is significant.
The challenge is finding a high-throughput way to filter those amateur board games. We like to think the best games will rise to the top, but at scale this becomes a popularity contest.
Furthermore, the line between amateur and professional blurs quickly when the amateurs start selling their products. Once someone starts a Kickstarter or opens a store to sell their amateur board game, they are effectively professionals. They tend to start behaving as such.
- xpe 6y ago> Furthermore, the line between amateur and professional blurs quickly when the amateurs start selling their products. Once someone starts a Kickstarter or opens a store to sell their amateur board game, they are effectively professionals. They tend to start behaving as such. Yes, in the sense that they have to factor in "professional" responsibilities, such as paying attention to costs; e.g. production and marketing. However, I think when many people say "professional game designer" I think they may (rightly or wrongly) include "seasoned" (i.e. with a track record). Of course, both amateurs and professionals may be seasoned. And both may have passion and dedication to their work.
- irrational 6y ago> We like to think the best games will rise to the top, but at scale this becomes a popularity contest. There are 5,000 new board games released every year (and that isn't even including expansions to previously release games). The challenge is sifting through thousands of new games to pick out the wheat from the chaff. The games from popular designers are much more likely to be successful than from up and comers. I often wonder how many gems among those 5,000 games never get noticed.