4 ms·
I'm somewhat curious what happens to the long standing 4P/4U servers from companies like Dell and HP. The Ryzen/EPYC has really made going past 2P/2U a more ra
by tyingq 6y ago
I'm somewhat curious what happens to the long standing 4P/4U servers from companies like Dell and HP. The Ryzen/EPYC has really made going past 2P/2U a more rare need.
- wtallis 6y agoI think at this point the only reasons to go beyond 2U are to make room for either 3.5" hard drives, or GPUs.
- rektide 6y agoWould love to see some very dense blade style ryzen offerings. The 4 2P nodes in 2U is great. Good way to share some power supies, fan, chassis, ideally multi-home nic too. Turn those sleds into blades though, put em on their side, & go even denser. It should be a way to save costs, but density alas is a huge upsell, even though it should be a way to scale costs down.
- tanelpoder 6y agoIndeed, 128 EPYC cores in 2 sockets (with total 16 memory channels) will give a lot of power. I guess it's worth mentioning that the 64-core chips have much lower clock rate than 16/32 core ones though. And with some expensive software that's licensed by CPU core (Oracle), you'd want faster cores, but possibly pay a higher NUMA price when going with a single 4 or 8 sockets machine for your "sacred monolith".
- thinkingkong 6y agoYou might be able to buy a smaller server but the rack density doesnt necessarily change. You still have to worry about cooling and power so lots of DCs would have 1/4 or 1/2 racks.
- tyingq 6y agoSure. I wasn't really thinking of density, just the interesting start of the "death" of 4 socket servers. Being an old-timer, it's interesting to me because "typical database server" has been synonymous with 4P/4U for a long, long time.
- vinay_ys 6y agoI haven't seen a 4 socket machine in a long time.
- StillBored 6y agoThere always seems to be buyers for more exotic high end hardware. That market has been shrinking and expanding, well since the first computer, as mainstream machines become more capable and people discover more uses for large coherent machines. But users of 16 socket machines, will just step down to 4 socket epyc machines with 512 cores (or whatever). And someone else will realize that moving their "web scale" cluster from 5k machines, down to a single machine with 16 sockets results in lower latency and less cost. (or whatever).
- toast0 6y agoAt least when I was actively looking at hardware (2011-2018), 4 socket Xeon was available off the shelf, but at quite the premium over 2 socket Xeon. If your load scaled horizontally, it still made sense to get a 2P Xeon over 2x 1P Xeon, but 2x 2P Xeon was way more cost efficient than a 4P Xeon. 8P or 16P seemed to exist, but maybe only in catalogs. I'm not really in the market anymore, but Epyc looks like 1P is going to solve a lot of needs, and 2P will be available at a reasonable premium, but 4P will probably be out of reach.