7 ms·
> Non-zero chance had they not haulted trading on those symbols they would've been insolvent by close of trading today, depending on the size of their credit li
by michaelt 6y ago
> Non-zero chance had they not haulted trading on those symbols they would've been insolvent by close of trading today, depending on the size of their credit line.
Perhaps you can help me understand something.
In the absence of margin trading, if I deposit $100 of cash at my brokerage, then I order my broker to buy $100 worth of Stock A, how does credit and the possibility of bankruptcy enter into the transaction at all?
After all, if I give my kid $5 and send him to the store to buy some milk, he doesn't need to find 'liquidity' or a 'credit line' or risk bankruptcy.
- toyg 6y agoNot an expert by any means, but I know in the world of trading there is often the requirement of guarantees before transactions are accepted. It's like your kid, at the store, was asked to show he actually had $100, before his $5 could be accepted and milk handed over.
- irjustin 6y agoIn RH everyone who opens an account starts as an Instant amount. The Instant means any security sold you can immediately use that cash. Normally you can't go that. You have to wait 3 days for it to settle in the clearing House. The Instant accounts are using margin to make the cash instantly available.
- devoutsalsa 6y agoAnother small example. Robinhood gave me one share of GE when I joined. I didn’t want it, so I sold it and withdrew the money. I initiated the withdrawal request yesterday for $10.69. It’d be amusing to me to find they would have been fine if I only withdrew $10.68.
- itronitron 6y agoBased on my very limited knowledge, it is my understanding that banks/brokers don't actually consider the deposit to be valid until several days after the transaction. Even if you deposited cash they would probably find some way to delay letting you use the funds pending some 'internal checking'. So in Robinhood's case if there are many people depositing dollars to buy stock then that could be their reason or excuse to not have funds available for trading. Just a guess.
- LandR 6y agoYeah I forgot about a credit card payment that was due a number of years ago, before I had online banking. I went in 2 days before it was due and paid it cash. I still got a late penalty added brcause cash takes three days to clear. A bill under £2 and got hit with a fee of £20
- Wildgoose 6y agoIn the UK, cash paid at the institution in question clears the same day. If bundled with a cheque (rather than as two separate transactions) it will clear at the same time as the cheque. I had something similar happen to me many years ago. I took ATM cash from another account, plus what I had in my house and wallet, to make up the amount that an auto-paid credit card bill due on that same day would have sent me overdrawn. I avoided the overdraft penalties.
- LandR 6y agoThe most absurd thing was that the bank, RBOS, callee me few days after about the late fee asking me if i was having money problems... It was a bill under £2 that had just slipped my mind. If they had checked any of my other accounts they would have seen that i had about £50k with them.. . But no a £2 bill has them calling me almost sounding like they were shaming me over an inconsequential amount of money!
- iNic 6y agoThe people using Robinhood are to some degree trading on margin, that means that they are trading with money they don't have in their account, which means that Robinhood also does not have it, at least not from you. They need to have a buffer of money to deal with the borrowing, which in this case they almost ran out of.
- rattray 6y agoIs that knowingly trading on margin, or just how it works behind the scenes? If the latter, why?
- cashewchoo 6y agoThe financial system is slow. ACH can take days before you can be sure things won't be reversed, trades take two days to settle, there's various anti-money-laundering policies everywhere that generally take the form of holding on to money for a bit to make shady things easier to track and detect. So, anyway, for lots of reasons, things that users think should be instant, aren't. And that's really bad UX, especially for a platform that depends so much on emotional stuff: "deposit $200 bucks and buy 3 shares of X, leaving you with a $30 cash deposit which RH can then earn interest on" is probably how a large amount of RH's balances come into being. That breaks if it's going to be a 1-day gap between someone depositing their money and then buying the shares. So everyone papers over holes like this with margin.
- ryandrake 6y agoIt's amazing that we still accept financial transactions taking days to actually "clear." Surely there's a market opportunity for someone to invent a way to do these anti-money-laundering things without delaying transactions. It's astounding that in 2021, it takes multiple days to increment a number in one database whilst decrementing that number in another database.
- disgrunt 6y agoIn this case, it has nothing to do with trading on margin and everything to do with Robin Hood having to cover 10% with the NSCC per the Dodd-Frank rule. [0] [0]: https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/cash-strapped-robinhood-scrambles-raise-1-billion-rich https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/cash-strapped-robinhood-sc...
- nojito 6y agoTrades aren't immediate they take T+2 to clear. During that time frame, Robinhood has to put up collateral.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoCorrect. And more to the point, RH cannot use customer funds to cover that timeframe. It must be its own funds. And the requirement of funds to be covering (collateral) can change on them with very little warning
- rattray 6y agoWho determines the collateral required?
- bradleybuda 6y agoIt’s federal law, part of the Dodd-Frank reforms in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. I recommend this: https://twitter.com/kralctrebor/status/1354952686165225478?s=21 https://twitter.com/kralctrebor/status/1354952686165225478?s...
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoThe NSCC sets the framework, but it is spelled out in Dodd-Frank that they have to do so by law. There are some other items, but that's the basic idea - full details are here: https://dtcc.com/-/media/Files/Downloads/legal/policy-and-compliance/NSCC_Disclosure_Framework.pdf https://dtcc.com/-/media/Files/Downloads/legal/policy-and-co... If you want to dive further i recommend this thread : https://mobile.twitter.com/KralcTrebor/status/1354952686165225478 https://mobile.twitter.com/KralcTrebor/status/13549526861652...
- mzi 6y agoI only knows how it works in otc derivatives and then the collateral is equal to the cost of taking an offsetting position, and is calculated inter-day. But I would guess it is something similar on the stock market.
- rtkwe 6y agoThey have to have a certain amount to cover the value of all the stocks held by their clients so when 50% of their account holders have a stock that suddenly gains 2-20x value things get tight. In your analogy the price of the milk is relatively stable in the case of gamestop the value of the milk is fluctuating wildly between the time you sent the kid, when he got to the store, when he picked up the milk, etc etc. except the kid is legally required to deliver the milk or make you whole.
- rattray 6y ago> They have to have a certain amount to cover the value of all the stocks held by their clients Huh? I don't understand this. What do they have to hold and why?
- ehnto 6y agoI presume it's a safety mechanism required by the financial apparatus so that they can make their investors whole if they ask to withdraw all at once. Something that given the current circumstances is actually quite possible. But being candid, that's just a guess.
- disgrunt 6y agoIt's a Dodd-Frank rule apparently. [0] [0]: https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/cash-strapped-robinhood-scrambles-raise-1-billion-rich https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/cash-strapped-robinhood-sc...
- jkestner 6y agoIt’s an SEC rule to guard against brokers going insolvent. Trades are not instant transactions so there’s a lot of credit being floated for days. Good thread explaining this, though still complex: https://mobile.twitter.com/KralcTrebor/status/1354952686165225478 https://mobile.twitter.com/KralcTrebor/status/13549526861652...
- xur17 6y agoIt feels like slow movement of money in our financial system causes a lot of these problems. Customer deposits take several days to settle (during which time Robinhood has to front the funds). Settlement of the stock trades / transfer of collateral to the DCC likely takes several days, etc.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoThe real reason is as follows: You cannot use customer funds to cover dtcc collateral terms. Your milk example does not work, because you are not settling up the milk buy 2 days after. You settle your milk purchase on the spot.
- cashewchoo 6y agoHuh I didn't know that. The firm I worked for did self-clearing, and we had no customers (prop trading). I guess that means these requirements didn't really matter for us because everything was ours?
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoeven if you self clear , you are still a broker clearer and you end up touching the DTCC. This is exactly what Robinhood is doing too. This twitter user explains, although it gets quite technical: https://mobile.twitter.com/wallstcynic/status/1355013438154616835?prefetchtimestamp=1611896590777 https://mobile.twitter.com/wallstcynic/status/13550134381546... Look at the tweet at 7:41PM EST. " But if RH takes in 500m of new money and 300m buys GME, then at minimum they are looking at posting 30m+ from just that exposure at NSCC. They cannot use client money - RH has to use their own resources to post. And if GME stock drops, RH has to post the loss pre-settlement."
- lukeramsden 6y agoLast I heard, the DTCC have raised collateral requirements on GME from 1-3% to 100%. Seriously. That's the real reason clearing houses stopped accepting new orders on GME from brokers.
- floxy 6y agoIs there a way for a regular person to see the current DTCC collateral requirements for a particular stock?
- 6y ago