3 ms·
I am glad they addressed the philosophical question of whether shorting the stocks should be illegal. I have more confidence in our equities markets because of
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
I am glad they addressed the philosophical question of whether shorting the stocks should be illegal.
I have more confidence in our equities markets because of the existence of short sellers. I’m glad to know there are people researching companies that are not being honest about their financials.
If there were another way to incentivize finding these types of companies without short selling, I would be interested.
- mschuster91 6y ago> If there were another way to incentivize finding these types of companies without short selling, I would be interested. In ye olde times before the invention and institutionalization of short selling and other financial instruments, this kind of research was the responsibility of the media (to raise the alarm) and the SEC/police (to investigate claims with the authority of the government, and prosecute offenders). Unfortunately, most newsrooms have been "consolidated" or shut down entirely as the market for quality journalism has declined over the last decades, and there is an unhealthy "revolving door" between banks, hedge funds and other market players on one side, and regulatory agencies on the other side.
- kgwgk 6y agoShort selling is older than the SEC.
- cardiffspaceman 6y agoTrue. All this stuff was old-hat when the Tulip Mania "ended" in the 17th Century. There is even a tale about olive presses that reads a little like a futures contract's lifetime [1]. [1] https://www.thestreet.com/opinion/a-brief-history-of-stock-options-10595277 https://www.thestreet.com/opinion/a-brief-history-of-stock-o...
- pbronez 6y agoMaybe? I think it’s really useful to give people an economic incentive to do socially useful things, like pointing out when a company is in an unsustainable position before it literally starts locking out workers. Journalists are better spent digging into political situations that aren’t directly tradable. Even if you think journalists should do the research and make results public instead of funds doing the research and keeping it private (until they reveal their conclusions through trading), I think you want shorting available as a RESPONSE to the reporting. Why would the companies change their behavior in response to negative press if they aren’t subjected to economic pain for ignoring it?
- swiley 6y agoPut options let you take a bearish position without short selling. IMO it's a way less crazy way to do that.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Put options let you take a bearish position without short selling Put options can’t be written at scale without shorting.
- jmcqk6 6y agoAll a put option needs is cash backing it in order to write it. It doesn't require any stock. - Me, a long time wheel runner
- bluGill 6y agoThe problem with puts is they have a time frame. I'm bearish, but I don't know when there will be a top. The market can remain irrational long enough for puts to expire worthless.