8 ms·
The longest cell in the history of life
- stretchwithme 15y agoWhen you look at all the cables behind any collection of devices, the way they are tangled indicates the order in which they were installed and moved around. Unless someone took the initiative to straighten the mess out. Apparently, the human body is the same way. And no one has gotten around to cleaning up the mess. But all the wires work well enough.
- rokhayakebe 15y agoHow do we know if the wires work well enough? For example we can talk so our communication tools work well enough, but what if we were suppose to communicate telepathically, hence this form which works well enough limits our ability to even think properly? Or let's say if the wiring had a little tweak in it we could significantly expand our lifespan?
- TheAmazingIdiot 15y agoI believe the bigger ethics question is "Would we want to extend the length of an average life?" We can easily surmise that saving our parents and grandparents would be an awesome thing (in many circumstances). As an individual choice, having loved ones around longer is good. It gets stickier ethically the further we move away from the individual and go more towards populations. Where do we put them? Do we warehouse them? How do we manage to feed the bigger population? What will they do, as they must work? And then there's the big scary word: Eugenics. It was advocated in the 1920's by Sanger, and later by the Nazis. However nasty the connotations are, China is currently going down this very path by taxation and restriction on number of children. Discussions that we thought were closed will come reopened rather quickly, when we have 10+ billion people here. Hopefully, we'll be mature, as a citizen of the world, to discuss these problems.
- rokhayakebe 15y agoWhere do we put them?.....as they must work? I think these questions could be answered if we truly spent enough ressources on them. We can scale up as opposed to horizontally. Food could be produced in labs and have more nutrients and taste better.
- TheAmazingIdiot 15y agoYou make a decent emotional appeal. However, the hard facts we are dealing with today is the aftermath of the Baby Boomers. Normally, when we deal with population graphs, we see a huge base of young, a smaller base of young adults, smaller base of mid adults, and a small/pinnacle of elderly. It's supposed to taper off into a long tail. Instead, we in the US (unsure about other cultures and areas) a huge bulge around 55-65. Social programs are meant to subsidise the elder through the younger. However in this situation, there's not enough younger to pay for the same care the elder have been receiving. So you either raise the age cap, or reduce service. And, AARP makes sure the second choice doesn't happen. And about the food quip: back in 2000, the global food output was enough to feed 12 earths of people, yet people still died of hunger. Overall resource maintenance and allocation is the bigger, and unsolved problem.
- nopassrecover 15y agoPresumably if we could extend life, we could also extend the period of life in which you can produce and create useful things. There would be little point extending lives if it meant you spent an extra 30 years confined to a bed with no memory of your identity.
- TheAmazingIdiot 15y agoThat's part of what I'm worried about. Upper middle class and above have little to no qualms about throwing scads of money at a little bit of extra time here, even if the quality of that time is approaching 0. And in the baby boomers case, they expect the government to send in their due. When that comes, though, we will not be able to afford it. It's kind of what we talk a lot about in the entrepreneurial sense: We try to convert time to money in a reproducible sense. However, the older you get, money depreciates to 0 (dead people have no use for money), so you run that equation backwards, with large inefficiencies. But this kind of talk seems to piss off the bulk of downvoters. So be it.
- stretchwithme 15y agobecause the species has survived and flourished. still, there is some indication that not all have enough blood circulating to the right places.
- ilcavero 15y agoRichard Dawkins shows the giraffe nerve in a video (warning: dead giraffe in the video): http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xdm5he_richard-dawkins-demonstrates-laryngeal-nerve-of-the-giraffe_tech http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xdm5he_richard-dawkins-demo...
- baddox 15y agoI want to mention, in case anyone is uninformed, that the giraffe is not endangered and in fact is in the Least Concern category according to the IUCN.
- kiba 15y agoI wonder what would happens if the larynx nerve cell were actually redesigned properly.
- burgerbrain 15y agoYou could probably surgically test that. My money is on "not much" though. ;)
- majmun 15y agoSignals from brain to some part would go faster few microseconds i guess, and vice versa. And maybe few other hard to reproduce consequences. But why assume that this is bad designed in first place? We can't only by it's look conclude that it is bad design. Most of internal organs don't look nice anyway but they do the job. (they are in fact intended to look bad so average person would get upset if it see it)
- dhughes 15y agoYou would have an overwhelming desire to become an Auctioneer.
- BoppreH 15y agoIt seems this nerve also controls breathing, so maybe we would be less susceptible to fractures and cuts rupturing it? Could be a tiny, but measurable increase in survival chance. Edit Apparently it's also a concern during invasive surgeries: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recurrent_laryngeal_nerve#Clinical_significance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recurrent_laryngeal_nerve#Clini...
- wbhart 15y agoThis is an excellent point. The article is pretty badly written, and oversimplified, I think. If the argument is somehow that this is evidence of evolution (an argument that is never made in the article, but only ever implied), and therefore evidence that there is no design to life (a pretty specious argument in the first place in my opinion), then the article should at least describe how this should have been plumbed, what the consequences of that would be and why it would be better. The article does not even try to establish that there is no functional reason that it is plumbed this way in mammals. Actually, it doesn't even explain what the function of the nerve is. It is left to the reader to guess. Most importantly, the article does not try to explain why there is an evolutionary obstacle to looping the nerve around the other side of the aorta. It argues that it is "monumentally inefficient" to do it this way, something that evolution should abhor, but does not even try to explain why evolution is so constrained. It seems to me to be a science of the gaps argument. Despite the overwhelming appearance of design in nature, which is not disputed even by many atheists, they seem to be trying to argue for {insert favourite naturalistic theory of origins here} based upon personal ignorance of how a perfect designer would go about doing this. I'm not clear why this even made it to the front page of HN. It seems to have been written solely to stir up debate with people who believe in intelligent design. I think I'd prefer to stick to coding, science and technology.
- TheRevoltingX 15y agoI wonder why this person thinks that we were created in perfection. Even the bible points out this is far from the truth. Just sayin'
- burgerbrain 15y agoI think you are misunderstanding. The primary purpose of this is to point out that what we would expect to happen with evolution in mind does in fact seem to happen. The data jives with the theory. Now, the secondary purpose is to provide some amusing snark: Anything that would "design" such a thing would be anything but "intelligent". The bible really has nothing to do with this.
- TheRevoltingX 15y agoNo, I like the article and I'm not arguing against it. Just wondering where people get the idea that we were somehow designed to be perfect. The bible has a lot to do with that since it's a standard upon which (at least for the most part in America) the idea of God is derived from. Seems like a lot of people don't even know what they don't believe in so they make it up.
- alnayyir 15y agoActually the details are irrelevant. The entire premise can be disregarded out of hand. That anybody bothers to address specifics such as this post, or matters of dogma/biblical interpretation is more to make it relatable than relevant. Because it's not relevant. The entire epistemic concept of a "Creator" who is supernatural is nonsensical, and without any superior merit to any other meaningless hypothesis.
- TheRevoltingX 15y agoWait, so it's not relevant to ask why people think a way they think? I mean if someone makes such an uneducated assumption it makes me question their logic in general.
- hoggle 15y agoI doubt that this animal died by a natural cause. I've been an atheist all my life and especially because of that it saddens me to witness the slaughter of an animal for the sake of fundamental research in order to debunk a nonsensical belief in the first place.
- coffeedrinker 15y agoI don't follow the creation v. evolution debate so this was new to me. I did google to see what the other side says about this and found this interesting: "Human-designed devices, such as radios and computers, do not need to function until their assembly is complete. By contrast, living organisms must function to a high degree in order to thrive during every developmental stage from a single-cell zygote to adult. The embryo as a whole must be a fully functioning system in its specific environment during every second of its entire development. For this reason, adult anatomy can be understood only in the light of development." http://www.icr.org/article/recurrent-laryngeal-nerve-not-evidence/ http://www.icr.org/article/recurrent-laryngeal-nerve-not-evi... I do not vouch for the science behind either article, but the concept that everything must work all the time rather than only at completion is an interesting concept that shows the difference between things I make and how I was made.
- epistasis 15y agoI'd disagree heartily with that quote. During development, multi-cellular organisms aren't "fully functional." They survive, but in barely functional states, in wombs, cocoons, or eggs. Organisms do have to self-assemble though, which is pretty damn cool.
- burgerbrain 15y ago"They survive" Since that is their primary purpose, that's pretty fully functional in my book.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ToastOpt 15y agoHuman designed devices _also_ function in this regard throughout their assembly. Varying the definition of "function" for only one side would make the argument spurious.
- 15y ago
- moonboots 15y agoMaybe god just sucks at design
- Daniel_Newby 15y agoAnother example are the nerve fibers that dilate the eyes. They travel down the spinal cord, exit at the base of the neck into a ganglion, travel back up along the carotid artery into the brain, and finally connect to the eye.