2 ms·
I don’t know what Robinhood is actually doing, but I think your scenario isn’t necessarily problematic. Suppose I deposit $100 and Butt $300 of stock. Now I ha
by amluto 6y ago
I don’t know what Robinhood is actually doing, but I think your scenario isn’t necessarily problematic.
Suppose I deposit $100 and Butt $300 of stock. Now I have -$200 of cash. (The UI doesn’t necessarily show it like that, but that’s what’s in my account.). If the stock goes up to $600, I still have -$200 of cash. If the stock drops to $400, I still have -$200 of cash. If the volatility estimates change such that a rapid crash to $199 seems likely, the broker should margin call me, as a crash to $199 would send my account value negative.
Contrast this with non-margin trading. If I deposit $400 and buy $300 of stock, I have $100 of cash, and the broker doesn’t particularly care what happens to the stock price, since they are taking no risk. Their clearer may impose requirements on them, but that’s a somewhat separate issue.