I thought about it, but honestly it took a lot of time and energy out of me already, I just don't want to deal with them again. I just won't ever do business w

I thought about it, but honestly it took a lot of time and energy out of me already, I just don't want to deal with them again. I just won't ever do business with them again, and I tell my story from time to time to people that ask my opinion about ISPs. I'm not even sure I have a case, I looked a bit online and as you said, lying is not illegal even if in cases like this that doesn't sit very well with me. In your case, isn't having a counter notice mechanism a requirement? I guess you could have sued them as well for that? But I understand, I don't want to have to sue every company I do business with, that's not a healthy environment even though it probably would be better for everyone in the long run.