5 ms·
customer reviews aren't really a 'democracy'. They're supposed to be authentic and reflect the overall quality of the app to the general user. A horde of outra
by Barrin92 6y ago
customer reviews aren't really a 'democracy'. They're supposed to be authentic and reflect the overall quality of the app to the general user.
A horde of outraged users bombarding the app even though most people won't care about this particular event distorts the rating comparable to disappointed TV viewers bombing imdb. It ruins the utility for everyone else.
- bazooka_penguin 6y agoI think the review is meant to reflect the entire product, not just the app. That includes robinhood's service, they're not separate. And robinhood passed a lot of people off by restricting the buying of certain stock. The backlash is warranted
- aplummer 6y agoSadly for me a lot of the apps I've made I'm pretty happy with are filled with reviews that basically say "Sally in customer service was mean, 1 star".
- jimmydorry 6y agoThat is part of the customer experience. If Google / Apple really wanted to, they could give more than one dimenion to score on. For example, a five star rating for app quality, fun, and customer service. That they don't shouldn't preclude customers from rating the entire experience.
- aplummer 6y agoYeap I think that is the feature I would like. I still think it’s fine they rate the whole thing by the way, just sad for me!
- quantummkv 6y agoThat's how reviews are supposed to function. If the users are outraged at the app for what they feel was wrong behavior by the app and it's associated service, they are entitled to it. Just as I am entitled to leave a glowing review if the issue does not affect me.
- mike00632 6y agoEvery product has a defect rate and outraged customers are the most likely to post reviews. Therefore a product is likely to have an overrepresented proportion of negative reviews. This is a tricky problem to correct for. I'm thinking about this more in terms of Amazon reviews, where they perhaps factor in the rate of returns when deciding what and how many reviews to delete.
- mech422 6y agothat just means the reviews skew lower, not that they need to be 'corrected for'... If a good product has 1K 'bad reviews', and a crap product has 10K 'bad reviews' - the system it working. Anything else is just gaming the system to inflate review scores across the board.
- mike00632 6y agoWhen I shop for products on Amazon the problem is such that more or less all reviews are negative. In that case it doesn't matter if it's 1k or 10k, they simply drown out the positive/neutral reviews, even though I'm pretty safe to ignore the "this product was DOA" reviews. The review incentive structure is fundamentally broken.
- mech422 6y agoeh - you can actually read all the reviews by rating... if you feel only 3 star reviews are valuable, amazon lets you read just the 3 star reviews. If stuff is being 'drowned out' its because your trying to read all 500 pages of reviews? To me, a much bigger problem is the fact that reviews on amazon are for totally different products then whats being sold (Sellers 'recycle' pages and change the product being sold - allowing them to keep the reviews and ratings) So basically - I have to read the reviews 'most recent' first anyway..
- quantummkv 6y ago> Every product has a defect rate and outraged customers are the most likely to post reviews. Therefore a product is likely to have an overrepresented proportion of negative reviews. If I buy a product or a service, and it is defective or not what what was promised or not upto mark, I have the right to complain about it. Shutting down my valid complains because it would create an overrepresented proportion of negative reviews is downright wrong.
- 8note 6y agoSupposing YouTube looked great, but they turned off the ability to watch videos, it'd also get a 1 star review from me.